Love and Truth

Authored By: Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew

Love and Truth

Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew

On relations between Catholics and Orthodox

Established on 4 November 1964 by the Austrian Cardinal Franz König, the Pro Oriente Foundation was born from the Second Vatican Council and from the desire to improve relations between the Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox Churches, as stated in the Decree on ecumenism Unitatis Redintegratio. The foundation is based in Vienna and it was there that they celebrated the 50th anniversary of its founding in the Archbishop’s residence. The President, Johann Marte, organized a conference in which, among others, participated: Cardinal Kurt Koch, President of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity; Cardinal Christoph Schönbom, Archbishop of Vienna; Patriarch of the Coptic Orthodox Church Tawadros II; and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew. The following are excerpts of the Ecumenical Patriarch's address.

It is indeed a particular privilege and honor to be invited to address you on the auspicious occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Pro Oriente Foundation. This event marks a special and significant milestone in the history of relations between the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Churches. In many ways it is a mirror of the relations between our Churches inasmuch as it reflects and parallels the extraordinary steps of rapprochement and reconciliation that began half a century ago and have led to the theological dialogue and sincere exchanges between us on the parish and local, regional and national, as well as international levels.

As you are all aware, in a few days, our beloved brother in Christ, Pope Francis, will visit Istanbul, which has served as the sacred center and sec of the Ecumenical Patriarchate for over 17 centuries. We very much look forward to welcoming His Holiness to the Phanar on 29-30 November [2014] for the commemoration of St Andrew the first-called of the Apostles and Thronal Feast of the Church of Constantinople. This official visit follows in the wake of our joint pilgrimage to Jerusalem only a few months ago to celebrate another 50th anniversary, namely the journey to the Holy Land by the late Pope — now officially proclaimed Saint in the Roman Catholic Church — Paul VI and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras. We were deeply touched that Pope Francis accepted our invitation for a common observance of that occasion, which we proposed to him during our own attendance at his enthronement and solemn Inaugural Mass in March 2013.

Dear listeners, these instances are not purely coincidental; nor again are they merely historical. We would dare to say that they are in fact nothing less than providential. Fifty years ago, such events would not have been conceivable or even achievable. It is surely the grace of God that inspired our venerable and visionary predecessors to assume these bold initiatives. In some ways, after so many years of estrangement and silence, only the Spirit of God could possibly bring about the conditions and circumstances for greater partnership and closer relations between our Churches, which were previously alienated for an entire millennium. It is precisely within such an atmosphere of ecumenical openness and sincere desire for dialogue that the Pro Oriente Foundation was envisaged and established in 1964 by the Viennese bishop, the late Franz Cardinal König, who discerned the spirit of the times and perceived the importance of adhering to the commandment and prayer of our Lord, “that [His disciples] may be one”. (John 17.21) The sacred purpose and fundamental goal of the Foundation — with its various charters in Vienna, Graz, Salzburg and Linz — was to improve relations between the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox as well as Oriental Orthodox Churches, echoing the papal decree Unitatis Redintegratio issued on 21 November 1964, half a century ago. Its founding president was the renowned and respected Alfred Stirnemann, who led the Foundation until his death in 1988. We remember both of these leaders, together with our cherished departed friends, the late Metropolitans Chrysosotomos and his successor Michael of Austria, Patriarchal Exarchs of Hungary and Mid-Europe. These two Orthodox hierarchs were unconditionally convinced of the essential role of positive relations with the Roman Catholic Church, working tirelessly toward advancing dialogue and enhancing cooperation. May their memory be eternal and may their example be a model for us all!

Let us, however, recall some of the groundbreaking steps taken just over 50 years ago, which in turn led to the fertile conditions for the creation of a foundation such as Pro Oriente. In the opening days of 1964, Pope Paul VI and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras broke a silence of many centuries with just a few simple words and a loving embrace. On 5 January 1964, when Pope Paul VI met with Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras on the Mount of Olives, it was the first time the Western pontiff and the Eastern primate — the Pope of Rome and the Archbishop of New Rome — were meeting face-to-face since the Council of Florence in 1438. And the venue for the encounter in 1964 was the very site where Christ addressed His Father on the night of His betrayal for the unity of His followers. Prior to this meeting, for many centuries the Eastern and Western Churches had no formal contact and little unofficial communication. After what is today known as the “great schism” of 1054, there were two brief encounters of exchange and dialogues of reunification at the Council of Lyon in 1274 and at the Council of Ferrara-Florence in 1438-39; yet both occasions left feelings of bitterness rather than hopefulness. The estrangement was further accentuated and sealed after the tragic events of the Crusades, especially the Fourth Crusade with the sack of Constantinople in 1202-04 with the unjustifiable slaughter of Christians by Christians.

Thus began the historical “dialogue of love” — a term coined by the late Metropolitan Meliton of Chalcedon — which in turn initiated a process of gradually breaking down barriers created over centuries. It was followed one year later — in a Joint Declaration read simultaneously at St Peter's in Rome and in the Patriarchal Church of St George in Istanbul — by the unprecedented “mutual lifting of the anathemas” on 7 December 1965, when the same two prelates “removed from both the memory and the midst of the Church the sentences of excommunication” dating back to 1054, agreeing that “the past be confided to the mercy of God”.

The year 1969 saw the beginning of a paramount and hitherto uninterrupted tradition, namely the exchange of formal annual delegations at the respective Patron Feasts of our two “sister churches” — in Rome on 29 June for the Feast of Saints Peter and Paul; and in Istanbul on 30 November which Pope Francis will honor at the end of this month. These momentous initiatives later culminated in the creation — during the papal visit to the Phanar on 30 November 1979 — of the Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church. Thus, the Holy See and 14 autocephalous Orthodox Churches commenced an official theological “dialogue of truth” on 29 May 1980 — during the tenure of our revered predecessor, the late Ecumenical Patriarch Dimitrios and the successor to Pope Paul VI, the late Pope John Paul II — in order to expand the “dialogue of love” and examine jointly the doctrinal differences between the two sister Churches.

Thankfully today, through the important and influential contribution of such foundations and institutes as Pro Oriente, this spirit of fraternal love and mutual respect has replaced the old. theological polemic and reciprocal suspicion. Of course, we are realistic enough to recognize that much remains to be achieved, and the path sometimes seems long and laborious. There are the thorny theological issues of primacy and collegiality, which are currently on the table for deliberation; and there is the delicate problem of Uniatism, which has already once suspended the dialogue. However, we must confess that there is no alternative path to dialogue and reconciliation.

As we declared jointly in Jerusalem with His Holiness Pope Francis: “We express our shared profound concern for the situation of Christians in the Middle East and for their right to remain full citizens of their homelands. In trust we turn to the almighty and merciful God in a prayer for peace in the Holy Land and in the Middle East in general. We especially pray for the Churches in Egypt, Syria, and Iraq, which have suffered most grievously due to recent events. We encourage all parties regardless of their religious convictions to continue to work for reconciliation and for the just recognition of peoples’ rights. We are persuaded that it is not arms, but dialogue, pardon and reconciliation that are the only possible means to achieve peace”. Permit us paternally to urge you to focus more of your attention toward this crisis.

The ecumenical work of Pro Oriente has proved invaluable and instrumental for the promotion of closer and stronger relations between our Churches. Its work has undoubtedly been both remarkable and admirable. Yet, as we all know, in our world, the work of unity remains constant and unceasing until the fullness of the heavenly kingdom. It is, therefore, our humble vocation and moral obligation to continue and reinforce our efforts toward reconciliation. Let us not simply preserve the memory of the pioneers of this blessed Foundation; let us carry on their example and increase their endeavors. For this would be the best commemoration and celebration of their legacy and longing for Christian unity.

L'Osservatore Romano
Weekly Edition in English
21 November 2014, page 16

For subscriptions to the English edition, contact:
Our Sunday Visitor: L'Osservatore Romano

New call-to-action