My understanding is that the vast majority of bishops throughout the world recognize that flu is not passed on through ingestion and have not tried to inhibit anyone from communicating on the tongue; but for those unfortunate enough to be in a diocese where such a "ban" is in place -- and for those not willing to comply -- how should they respond if constantly denied Communion? With resignation or defiance -- i.e. would it be worth contacting the Holy See? Surely the only justification for denying anyone a sacrament would be if he were a public sinner?

Gary--

A communicant should not be denied Communion for refusing to cooperate with the just request of the chief shepherd of his diocese that he receive Communion in the hand as a matter of protection for others, but neither should he be considering himself a "white martyr" when he is incorrectly denied. What should happen is that a pastor should thoroughly train his EMHCs in distributing Communion and catechize his parishioners about the higher reverential value of filial obedience to lawful superiors so that such instances do not occur.

Recommended reading:

Can my bishop order me to receive Communion in the hand?

Michelle Arnold
Catholic Answers

COPYRIGHT 2009

Click here to send this Question and Answer to a friend