ECCLESIA IN EUROPA
OF HIS HOLINESS
POPE JOHN PAUL II
TO THE BISHOPS
MEN AND WOMEN
IN THE CONSECRATED LIFE
AND ALL THE
ON JESUS CHRIST
ALIVE IN HIS CHURCH
THE SOURCE OF HOPE FOR
A proclamation of joy for Europe
1. The Church in Europe was closely united to her Bishops as they gathered in
Synod a second time and contemplated Jesus Christ, alive in his Church, the
source of hope for Europe.
This is a theme which I too wish to proclaim to all the Christians of Europe at
the beginning of this third millennium, as I join my Brother Bishops in
repeating the words of the First Letter of Saint Peter: “Have no fear, nor be
troubled, but in your hearts reverence Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to
make a defence to any one who calls you to account for the hope that is in you”
This proclamation resounded throughout the Great Jubilee of the Year 2000. The
Synod was celebrated on the eve of the Jubilee and was closely connected with
that event, serving as a kind of door opening upon the Jubilee.2 The Jubilee itself was “one unceasing hymn of praise to the Trinity”, an
authentic “journey of reconciliation” and a “sign of true hope for all who look
to Christ and to his Church”.3 Bequeathing to us the joy of a living encounter with Christ, “the same
yesterday, today and for ever” (Heb 13:8), it once again set before us
the Lord Jesus as the one unshaken foundation of authentic hope.
A second Synod for Europe
2. From the outset, a deeper appreciation of the theme of hope was the principal
goal of the Second Special Assembly for Europe of the Synod of Bishops. As the
last of a series of continental Synods celebrated in preparation for the Great
Jubilee of the Year 2000,4 its purpose was to analyze the situation of the Church in Europe and to offer
guidance in promoting a new proclamation of the Gospel, as I emphasized when I
announced its convocation on 23 June 1996, at the conclusion of the Eucharist
celebrated at the Olympic Stadium in Berlin.5
The synodal Assembly had to take up, re-examine and study the issues which
surfaced in the preceding Synod for Europe, which was held in 1991, following
the collapse of the walls, on the theme: “That we may be witnesses of Christ who
has set us free”. That first Special Assembly emphasized the urgent need for a
“new evangelization”, in the awareness that “Europe today must not simply appeal
to its former Christian heritage: it needs to be able to decide about its future
in conformity with the person and message of Jesus Christ”.6
Nine years later, the conviction that “the Church has the urgent task of
bringing the liberating message of the Gospel to the men and women of Europe”
once more emerged with compelling force. The theme chosen for the
new synodal Assembly set forth that same challenge, this time from the standpoint
of hope. There was a need, in other words, to proclaim this message of hope
to a Europe which seems to have lost sight of it.8
The experience of the Synod
3. The synodal Assembly, which met from 1 to 23 October 1999, was a precious
opportunity for encounter, listening and dialogue: it enabled Bishops from
different parts of Europe to have a better knowledge of one another and of the
Successor of Peter. As a group we were able to support and inspire one another,
thanks above all to the witness of those who under the former totalitarian
regimes endured harsh and prolonged persecutions on account of their faith.9
Once again we experienced moments of communion in faith and charity, led
by a desire to bring about a fraternal “exchange of gifts” and mutually enriched
by the diversity of each other's experiences.10
This led in turn to a readiness to hear the call which the Spirit makes to the
Particular Churches in Europe to face new challenges with decision.11
With a loving gaze the participants in the Synod did not hesitate
to look at the present reality of the Continent, noting both its light
and its shadows. There was a clear recognition that the current situation is
marked by grave uncertainties at the levels of culture, anthropology, ethics and
spirituality. There was also a clear and growing desire to understand more
deeply and to interpret this situation in order to see the tasks which await the
Church: what resulted were “useful orientations to make the face of Christ
increasingly more visible through a more incisive proclamation confirmed by a
4. The Synod experience, lived with evangelical discernment, also led to a
growing awareness of the unity that, without denying the differences
derived from historical situations and events, links the various parts of Europe. It is a unity which, rooted in a common Christian inspiration, is capable of
reconciling diverse cultural traditions and which demands, at the level of both
society and Church, a constant growth in mutual knowledge open to an increased
sharing of individual values.
Throughout the Synod, a powerful impulse towards hope gradually became
evident. While taking seriously the analyses of the complexity
characterizing the Continent, the Synod Fathers saw that possibly the most
urgent matter Europe faces, in both East and West, is a growing need for hope, a
hope which will enable us to give meaning to life and history and to continue on
our way together. All the reflections of the Synod were geared towards
responding to this need, taking as their starting-point the mystery of Christ
and the Trinity. The Synod wished to set forth once more the figure of
Jesus, alive in his Church, who reveals God as Love, a communion of the three
The icon of the Book of Revelation
5. In this Post-Synodal Exhortation I am pleased to be able to share with the
Church in Europe the fruits of this Second Special Assembly for Europe of the
Synod of Bishops. In this way I intend to respond to the desire expressed at the
end of the synodal Assembly, when the Fathers gave me the texts of their
reflections and asked me to offer to the pilgrim Church in Europe a document on
the theme of the Synod.13
“He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the Churches” (Rev
2:7). In proclaiming to Europe the Gospel of hope, I will take as a guide the
Book of Revelation, a “prophetic revelation” which discloses to the
community of believers the deep and hidden meaning of what is taking place (cf.
Rev 1:1). The Book of Revelation sets before us a word addressed to
Christian communities, enabling them to interpret and experience their place in
history, with all its questions and its tribulations, in the light of the
definitive victory of the Lamb who was slain and who rose from the dead. At the
same time, it sets before us a word which calls on us to live in a way which
rejects the recurring temptation to construct the city of man apart from God or
even in opposition to him. For should this ever happen, human society itself
would sooner or later meet with irreversible failure.
The Book of Revelation contains a word of encouragement addressed to believers:
beyond all appearances, and even if its effects are not yet seen, the victory of
Christ has already taken place and is final. This in turn causes us to approach
human situations and events with an attitude of fundamental trust, born of faith
in the Risen One, present and at work in history.
JESUS CHRIST IS OUR HOPE
“Fear not, I am the first and the last and the living one” (Rev 1:17-18)
The Risen One is always with us
6. At a time of persecution, tribulation and bewilderment for the Church (cf.
Rev 1:9), the message resounding throughout the vision of the writer of the
Book of Revelation is a message of hope: “Fear not, I am the first and
the last, and the living one, I died and behold I am alive for ever more, and I
have the keys of Death and Hades” (Rev 1:17-18). We thus find ourselves
before the Gospel, the “good news”, that is Jesus Christ himself. He is
the First and the Last: in him all history finds its beginning, its
meaning, its direction and its fulfilment. In him and with him, in his death and
resurrection, everything has already been said. He is the Living One:
once he was dead yet now he lives for ever. He is the Lamb standing
before the throne of God (cf. Rev 5:6): sacrificed, because he
shed his blood for us on the wood of the Cross. He is standing, because
he has come back to unending life and has shown us the infinite power of the
Father's love. He holds in his hands the seven stars (cf Rev 1:16), the persecuted Church of God, which struggles against evil and sin,
yet nonetheless has every right to be joyful and victorious since she is in the
hands of the One who has already triumphed over evil. He walks among the
seven golden lampstands (cf. Rev 2:1), for he is present and active
in his Church at prayer. He is also “the one who comes” (Rev 1:4),
thanks to the Church's mission and the activity throughout human history;
he will come as the eschatological reaper, at the end of time, in order to bring
all things to completion (cf. Rev 14:15- 16; 22:20).
I. Challenges and signs of hope for the Church in Europe
The dimming of hope
7. This message is also addressed today to the Churches in Europe,
often tempted by a dimming of hope. The age we are living in, with its own
particular challenges, can seem to be a time of bewilderment. Many men and women
seem disoriented, uncertain, without hope, and not a few Christians share these
feelings. There are many troubling signs
which at the beginning of the third millennium are clouding the horizon
of the European continent, which “despite great signs of faith and witness
and an atmosphere undoubtedly more free and unified, feels all the weariness
which historical events – recent and past – have brought about deep within
the hearts of its peoples, often causing disappointment”.14
Among the aspects of this situation, so many of which were frequently mentioned
during the Synod,15 I would like to mention in a particular way the loss of Europe's
Christian memory and heritage, accompanied by a kind of practical
agnosticism and religious indifference whereby many Europeans give the
impression of living without spiritual roots and somewhat like heirs who have
squandered a patrimony entrusted to them by history. It is no real surprise,
then, that there are efforts to create a vision of Europe which ignore its
religious heritage, and in particular, its profound Christian soul, asserting
the rights of the peoples who make up Europe without grafting those rights on to
the trunk which is enlivened by the sap of Christianity.
Certainly Europe is not lacking in prestigious symbols of the Christian
presence, yet with the slow and steady advance of secularism, these symbols risk
becoming a mere vestige of the past. Many people are no longer able to integrate
the Gospel message into their daily experience; living one's faith in Jesus
becomes increasingly difficult in a social and cultural setting in which that
faith is constantly challenged and threatened. In many social settings it is
easier to be identified as an agnostic than a believer. The impression is given
that unbelief is self-explanatory, whereas belief needs a sort of social
legitimization which is neither obvious nor taken for granted.
8. This loss of Christian memory is accompanied by a kind of fear of the
future. Tomorrow is often presented as something bleak and uncertain. The
future is viewed more with dread than with desire. Among the troubling
indications of this are the inner emptiness that grips many people and the loss
of meaning in life. The signs and fruits of this existential anguish include, in
particular, the diminishing number of births, the decline in the number of
vocations to the priesthood and religious life, and the difficulty, if not the
outright refusal, to make lifelong commitments, including marriage.
We find ourselves before a widespread existential fragmentation. A
feeling of loneliness is prevalent; divisions and conflicts are on the rise.
Among other symptoms of this state of affairs, Europe is presently witnessing
the grave phenomenon of family crises and the weakening of the very concept of
the family, the continuation or resurfacing of ethnic conflicts, the
re-emergence of racism, interreligious tensions, a selfishness that closes
individuals and groups in upon themselves, a growing overall lack of concern for
ethics and an obsessive concern for personal interests and privileges. To many
observers the current process of globalization, rather than leading towards the
greater unity of the human race, risks being dominated by an approach that would
marginalize the less powerful and increase the number of poor in the world.
In connection with the spread of individualism, we see an increased weakening
of interpersonal solidarity: while charitable institutions continue to carry out praiseworthy work, one
notes a decline in the sense of solidarity, with the result that many people,
while not lacking material necessities, feel increasingly alone, left to
themselves without structures of affection and support.
9. At the root of this loss of hope is an attempt to promote a vision of man
apart from God and apart from Christ. This sort of thinking has led to man
being considered as “the absolute centre of reality, a view which makes him
occupy – falsely – the place of God and which forgets that it is not man who creates
God, but rather God who creates man. Forgetfulness of God led to the abandonment
of man”. It is therefore “no wonder that in this context a vast field has opened
for the unrestrained development of nihilism in philosophy, of relativism in
values and morality, and of pragmatism – and even a cynical hedonism – in daily
life”.16 European culture gives the impression of “silent apostasy” on the
part of people who have all that they need and who live as if God does not
This is the context for those attempts, including the most recent ones, to
present European culture with no reference to the contribution of the
Christian religion which marked its historical development and its universal
diffusion. We are witnessing the emergence of a new culture, largely
influenced by the mass media, whose content and character are often in conflict
with the Gospel and the dignity of the human person. This culture is also marked by an widespread and growing religious
agnosticism, connected to a more profound moral and legal relativism rooted in
confusion regarding the truth about man as the basis of the inalienable rights
of all human beings. At times the signs of a weakening of hope are evident in
disturbing forms of what might be called a “culture of death”.17
An irrepressible yearning for hope
10. Yet, as the Synod Fathers made clear, “man cannot live without hope:
life would become meaningless and unbearable”.18 Often those in need of hope believe that they can find peace in fleeting
and insubstantial things. In this way, hope, restricted to this world
and closed to transcendence, is identified, for example, with the paradise
promised by science or technology, with various forms of messianism, with a
hedonistic natural felicity brought about by consumerism, or with the imaginary
and artificial euphoria produced by drugs, with certain forms of millenarianism,
with the attraction of oriental philosophies, with the quest for forms of
esoteric spirituality and with the different currents of the New Age
All these, however, show themselves profoundly illusory and incapable
of satisfying that yearning for happiness which the human heart continues
to harbour. The disturbing signs of growing hopelessness thus continue and
intensify, occasionally manifesting themselves also in forms of aggression
Signs of hope
11. No human being can live without looking towards the future. How much more so
the Church, which lives in expectation of the Kingdom yet to come and already
present in this world. It would be unjust not to acknowledge the signs of
the influence of Christ's Gospel in the life of societies. The Synod
Fathers sought them out and emphasized them.
These signs must include the recovery of freedom of the Church in Eastern
Europe, with its new possibilities for pastoral activity; the concentration of
the Church on her spiritual mission and her primary commitment to
evangelization, also with regard for social and political realities; the growing
missionary awareness on the part of all the baptized in the variety and
complementarity of their gifts and their tasks, and the increased presence of
women in the life and structures of the Christian community.
A community of peoples
12. If we look at Europe as a civil community, signs of hope are
not lacking: when we consider these signs with the eyes of faith, we can
perceive, even amid the contradictions of history, the presence of the Spirit
of God, who renews the face of the earth. At the conclusion of their labours,
the Synod Fathers described these signs in the following way: “We joyfully
recognize the growing openness of peoples to one another, the
reconciliation between countries which have been hostile and at enmity with
each other for a long time, the progressive opening up to the countries
of Eastern Europe in the process of seeking deeper unity. Mutual recognition,
forms of cooperation and exchanges of all sorts are being developed in such
a way that little by little, a culture, indeed a European consciousness,
is being created. This we hope will encourage, especially among the young, a
sense of fraternity and the will to share. We note as a very positive factor
that the whole of this process is developing according to democratic
procedures, in a peaceful way and in the spirit of freedom which
respects and fosters legitimate diversity, encouraging and sustaining the
process leading to the growing unity of Europe. We welcome with satisfaction all that has been done to safeguard the
conditions and ways to respect human rights. Finally, in the context of
the legitimate economic and political unity in Europe, while acknowledging the
signs of hope seen by the attention given to the rights and to the quality of
life, we sincerely hope that, in creative fidelity to the humanist and
Christian traditions of our continent, there will be a guarantee of the primacy
of ethical and spiritual values”.21
Martyrs and witnesses to the faith
13. I intend, however, to draw particular attention to some of the signs which
have emerged in the life of the Church herself. In the first place, together
with the Synod Fathers, I want to point out to everyone, so that it will never
be forgotten, that great sign of hope represented by the many witnesses to
the Christian faith who lived in the last century, in both East and West.
They found suitable ways to proclaim the Gospel amid situations of hostility and
persecution, often even making the supreme sacrifice by shedding their blood.
These witnesses, and particularly those who suffered martyrdom, are an eloquent
and magnificent sign which we are called to contemplate and to imitate. They
show us the vitality of the Church; they stand before us as a light for the
Church and for humanity because they caused the light of Christ to shine in the
darkness; to the extent that they came from different religious traditions, they
also shine forth as a sign of hope for the journey of ecumenism, in the
certainty that their blood “is also a vital source of unity for the Church”.22
Even more radically, they tell us that martyrdom is the supreme
incarnation of the Gospel of hope: “In this way, martyrs proclaim 'the Gospel of
hope' and bear witnesses to it with their lives to the point of shedding their
blood, because they are certain that they cannot live without Christ and are
ready to die for him in the conviction that Jesus is the Lord and the Saviour of
humanity and that, therefore, only in him does mankind find true fullness of life. According to the exhortation of the Apostle
Peter, their example shown them ready to give reason for the hope that is in
them (cf. 1 Pt 3:15). Furthermore, martyrs celebrate the 'Gospel of
hope', because the offering of their lives is the greatest manifestation of the
living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which constitutes true spiritual
worship (cf. Rom 12:1), and the source, soul and summit of every
Christian celebration. Finally, martyrs serve the 'Gospel of hope', because they
express in their martyrdom a love and service of humanity to a high degree
insofar as they demonstrate that obedience to the law of the Gospel begets a
moral and societal life which honours and promotes the dignity and freedom of
The holiness of many
14. One fruit of the conversion brought about by the Gospel is the holiness
of so many men and women in our time: not only those whom the Church
has officially proclaimed saints, but all those who with simplicity and
amid the circumstances of their daily lives testified to their fidelity
to Christ. How can one not think of the countless sons and daughters of
the Church who throughout Europe's history have lived lives of generous
and authentic holiness in the hiddenness of their family and their professional
and social lives? “All of them like 'living stones' adhering to Christ 'the
cornerstone', have built Europe as a spiritual and moral edifice, leaving
a most precious inheritance to the future generations. The Lord Jesus promised:
'He who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works
than these will he do, because I go to the Father” (Jn 14:12). The saints are living proof of the
fulfilment of this promise, and they encourage the belief that this is possible
in the most difficult hours of history”.24
The parish and ecclesial movements
15. The Gospel continues to bear fruit in parish communities, among consecrated
persons, in lay associations, in groups devoted to prayer and the apostolate and
in various youth communities, as well as through the presence and growth of new
movements and ecclesial realities. In each of them the one Spirit finds ways of
awakening renewed dedication to the Gospel, generous openness to the service of
others, and a Christian life marked by Gospel radicalism and missionary zeal.
In today's Europe too, both in the post-Communist countries and in the West,
the parish, while in need of constant renewal,25 continues
to maintain and to carry out its particular mission, which is indispensable
and of great relevance for pastoral care and the life of the Church. The
parish is still a setting where the faithful are offered opportunities for
genuine Christian living and a place for authentic human interaction and
socialization, whether in the situations of dispersion and anonymity typical
of large modern cities or in areas which are rural and sparsely populated.26
16. At the same time, together with the Synod Fathers, I express my great esteem
for the presence and activity of the different apostolic associations and
organizations, and for Catholic Action in particular. I also wish to note the
significant contribution that, in fellowship with other ecclesial realities and
never in isolation from them, they can offer to new movements and to new
ecclesial communities. Such groups, in fact, “help Christians to live a more
radically evangelical life. They are a cradle for different vocations, and
they generate new forms of consecration. Above all, they promote the vocation of
the laity, and they help it to find expression in different spheres of life.
They favour the holiness of the people. They are able to be both the messenger
and the message for people who otherwise would not encounter the Church.
Frequently they promote the journey of ecumenism and they open the ways to
interreligious dialogue. They are an antidote to the spread of sects and an
invaluable aid to the spread of joy and life in the Church”.27
The journey of ecumenism
17. We give thanks to the Lord for the great and consoling sign of hope which is
the progress made in the journey of ecumenism under the standard of truth, charity and reconciliation. This is of the great gifts of the Holy Spirit
for a continent like Europe which gave rise to tragic divisions between
Christians during the second millennium and which still suffers from their
I am moved as I remember certain moments of great intensity experienced during
the synodal labours and the unanimous conviction, also expressed by the
Fraternal Delegates, that this journey – despite the problems which remain and the
new ones which are emerging – cannot be halted, but rather must continue with
renewed enthusiasm, with deeper determination and with a humble openness to
mutual forgiveness on the part of all. I readily agree with some of the
observations made by the Synod Fathers, since “the progress in ecumenical
dialogue, which has its deepest source in the same Word of God, represents a
sign of great hope for the Church of today: the growth of unity among Christians
is, in fact mutually enriching for all”.28 We need to “look with joy at the progress that has so far been made in the
dialogue both with our brethren of the Orthodox Churches and with those of the
Ecclesial Communities born of the Reformation, recognizing in them a sign of the
working of the Spirit, for which we must praise and thank the Lord”.29
II. Returning to Christ,
the source of all hope
Confessing our faith
18. From the synodal Assembly there emerged the clear and passionate certainty
that the Church has to offer Europe the most precious of all gifts, a gift which
no one else can give: faith in Jesus Christ, the source of the hope that does
not disappoint;30 a gift which is at the origin of the spiritual and cultural unity of the
European peoples and which both today and tomorrow can make an essential
contribution to their development and integration. After twenty centuries, the
Church stands at the beginning of the third millennium with a message which is
ever the same, a message which constitutes her sole treasure: Jesus Christ is
Lord; in him, and in no one else, do we find salvation (cf. Acts 4:12).
Christ is the source of hope for Europe and for the whole world, “and the Church
is the channel in which the grace pouring from the pierced Heart of the Saviour
flows and spreads”.31
This confession of faith causes our hearts and lips to raise “a joyful
confession of hope: 'Risen and living Lord, you are the new hope of the
Church and of humanity. You are the one true hope for the human family and for
history. Already in this life, and in the life to come you are “among us the
hope of glory” (Col 1:27). In you and with you, we find truth: our life has meaning, communion
is possible, diversity can become richness, and the power of the kingdom is at
work in history and helps to build the city of mankind. Love gives an eternal
value to human efforts. Suffering becomes salvific, life will conquer death, creation will
share in the glory of the children of God' ”.32
Jesus Christ our hope
19. Jesus Christ is our hope because he, the Eternal Word of God, who is always
with the Father (cf. Jn 1:18), loved us so much that he assumed our human
nature in all things but sin and shared in our life, for the sake of our
salvation. The profession of this truth stands at the very heart of our faith.
The loss of the truth about Jesus Christ, or a failure to comprehend that truth,
prevent us from appreciating and entering into the mystery of God's love and the
Jesus Christ is our hope because he reveals the mystery of the Trinity.
This is the core of the Christian faith, and it can still make a significant
contribution, as it has in the past, to the creation of structures which,
inspired by the great values of the Gospel or measuring itself against them, are
capable of promoting the life, history and culture of the different peoples of
Many are the spiritual roots underlying the recognition of the value of
the human person and his inalienable dignity, the sacredness of human life
and the centrality of the family, the importance of education and freedom
of thought, speech and religion, the legal protection of individuals and
groups, the promotion of solidarity and the common good, and the recognition
of the dignity of labour. These roots have helped lead to the submission
of political power to the rule of law and to respect for the rights of individuals
and peoples. Here we should mention the spirit of ancient Greece and Rome,
the contributions of the Celtic, Germanic, Slav and Finno-Ugric peoples
and the influence of Jewish and Islamic culture. Yet it must be acknowledged
that these inspiring principles have historically found in the Judeo-Christian
tradition a force capable of harmonizing, consolidating and promoting them.
This is a fact which cannot be ignored; on the contrary, in the process
of building a united Europe there is a need to acknowledge that this edifice
must also be founded on values that are are most fully manifested in the
Christian tradition. Such an acknowledgment is to everyone's advantage.
The Church “is not entitled to express preferences for this or that
institutional or constitutional solution” for Europe, and for this reason she
consistently desires to respect the legitimate autonomy of the civil order.34 Nevertheless, she has the task of reviving faith in the Trinity among the
Christians of Europe, knowing full well that this faith is the herald of
authentic hope for the continent. Many of the great paradigms of reference
mentioned above, which are at the core of European civilization, have their
deepest roots in the Church's trinitarian faith. This faith contains an
extraordinary spiritual, cultural and ethical potential which is also capable of
shedding light on some of the more important questions discussed in Europe
today, such as social disintegration and the loss of a meaningful point of
reference for life and history. Hence the need for a renewed theological,
spiritual and pastoral meditation on the mystery of the Trinity.35
20. The Particular Churches in Europe are not simple agencies or private
organizations. Rather, they carry out their work with a specific institutional
dimension that merits legal recognition, in full respect for just systems of
civil legislation. In their self-reflection, Christian communities need to
appreciate anew that they are a gift which God has given for the enrichment of
the peoples living on the continent. This is the joyful message that they are
called to bring to every person. In coming to a deeper appreciation of their own
essential missionary dimension, they must constantly testify that Jesus Christ
“is the one and only mediator of salvation for all of humanity. Only in
him do humanity, history and the cosmos find their definitively positive meaning
and receive their full realization: he has in himself in his life and in his
person the definitive reason of salvation. He is not only the mediator of
salvation but salvation's very source”.36
Consequently, in the context of the ethical and religious pluralism which
increasingly characterizes Europe, there is a need to profess and proclaim
the truth of Christ as the one Mediator between God and men and the one
Saviour of the world. Therefore, in union with the whole Church, I invite
my brothers and my sisters in faith – as I did at the end of the synodal
Assembly – constantly to be open in trust to Christ and to allow themselves
to be renewed by him, proclaiming to all people of good will in the power
of peace and love that whoever encounters the Lord comes to know the Truth,
discovers the Life, and finds the Way leading to it (cf. Jn 14:6;
Ps 15:11). From the tenor of life and the witness of Christians, the
inhabitants of Europe will come to discover that Christ is the future of man. In
the faith of the Church, “there is no other name under heaven given among men by
which we must be saved” (Acts 4:12).37
21. For believers, Jesus Christ is the hope of every person because he grants
eternal life. He is “the Word of life” (1 Jn 1:1), who came to the
world so that men and women “may have life, and have it abundantly” (Jn
10:10). He shows us that the true meaning of man's existence does not remain
confined within the horizons of this world, but opens instead upon eternity. The
mission of each Particular Church in Europe is to take note of every person's
thirst for truth and the need for authentic values which can enliven the people
living on the continent. With renewed energy, each Particular Church must again
bear witness to the newness which is its life. This means initiating a
well-structured cultural and missionary outreach, demonstrating by action and by
convincing arguments how the new Europe needs to rediscover its ultimate roots. In this context, all those who are
inspired by the values of the Gospel have an essential role to play, which is part of the solid
foundation for building a more humane and peaceful coexistence respectful of one
The Particular Churches in Europe need to restore to hope its primordially
True Christian hope, in fact, is theological and eschatological, founded on the
Risen One who will come again as Redeemer and Judge and who calls us to
resurrection and our eternal reward.
Jesus Christ alive in his Church
22. By returning to Christ, the peoples of Europe will be able to rediscover
the hope which alone can give full meaning to life. Today too they can discover
that hope, for Jesus is present, alive and at work in his Church. He is
in the Church and the Church is in him (cf. Jn 15:1ff.; Gal 3:28;
Eph 4:15-16; Acts 9:5). In the Church, by virtue of the gift of the
Holy Spirit, he unceasingly continues his saving work.39
With the eyes of faith we are enabled to see the mysterious presence of Jesus in
the different signs that he has left us. He is present first of all in Sacred
Scripture, which everywhere speaks of him (cf. Lk
24:27, 44-47). Yet in a unique way he is present in the Eucharist. This
“presence is called 'real' - by which it is not intended to exclude all
other types of presence as if they could not be 'real' too, but because it
is presence in the fullest sense: that is to say, it is a substantial presence by which Christ, the God-Man, is
wholly and entirely present”.40In the Eucharist, in fact, “is contained truly, really and
substantially the Body and the Blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, together with
his soul and divinity, and therefore the whole Christ”.41
“Truly the Eucharist is a mysterium fidei, a mystery which
surpasses our understanding and can only be received in faith”.42
Also real is the presence of Jesus in the other liturgical actions of the
Church, which she celebrates in his name. Among these are the Sacraments,
actions of Christ which he carries out at the hands of men.43
Jesus is also present in the world in other very real ways, and especially
through his disciples who, in fidelity to the twin commandment of love, worship
God in Spirit and truth (cf. Jn 4:24) and testify by their lives to the
fraternal love that sets them apart as followers of the Lord (cf. Mt
25:31-46; Jn 13:35; 15:1-17).44
THE GOSPEL OF HOPE ENTRUSTED TO THE CHURCH OF THE NEW MILLENNIUM
“Awake, and strengthen what remains and is on the point of death” (Rev 3:2)
I. The Lord calls to conversion
Jesus speaks today to our Churches
23. “The words of him who holds the seven stars in his right hand, who walks
among the golden lampstands..., the first and the last, who died and came to
life..., the Son of God” (Rev 2:1,8,18). It is Jesus himself who
speaks to his Church. His message is addressed to all the individual
Particular Churches and concerns their inner life, which is at times marked by
the presence of ideas and ways of thinking incompatible with the Gospel
tradition, frequently subjected to different forms of persecution and, what is
yet more dangerous, beset by troubling symptoms of worldliness, the loss of an
earlier faith, and compromise with the “logic” of the world. Not infrequently
communities have lost their first love (cf. Rev 2:4).
One sees how our ecclesial communities are struggling with weaknesses,
weariness and divisions. They too need to hear anew the voice of the Bridegroom,
who invites them to conversion, spurs them on to bold new undertakings and calls
forth their commitment to the great task of the “new evangelization”. The Church
must constantly submit to the judgment of Christ's word and live her human
reality in a state of purification, so as to be ever more perfectly the Bride
without spot or wrinkle, adorned with fine linen, bright and pure (cf. Eph
5:27; Rev 19:7-8).
In this way Jesus Christ is calling our Churches in Europe to conversion, and they, with their Lord and by the power of his presence, are becoming
bearers of hope for humanity.
The work of the Gospel throughout history
24. Europe has been widely and profoundly permeated by Christianity.
“There can be no doubt that, in Europe's complex history, Christianity has
been a central and defining element, established on the firm foundation
of the classical heritage and the multiple contributions of the various
ethnic and cultural steams which have succeeded one another down the centuries.
The Christian faith has shaped the culture of the Continent and is inextricably
bound up with its history, to the extent that Europe's history would be
incomprehensible without reference to the events which marked first the
great period of evangelization and then the long centuries when Christianity,
despite the painful division between East and West, came to be the religion
of the European peoples. Even in modern and contemporary times, when religious
unity progressively disintegrated as a result both of further divisions
between Christians and the gradual detachment of cultures from the horizon
of faith, the role played by faith has continued to be significant”.45
25. The Church's concern for Europe is born of her very nature
and mission. Down the centuries the Church has been closely linked to our
continent, so that Europe's spiritual face gradually took shape thanks to
the efforts of great missionaries, the witness of saints and martyrs, and
the tireless efforts of monks and nuns, men and women religious and pastors.
From the biblical conception of man Europe drew the best of its humanistic
culture, found inspiration for its artistic and intellectual creations,
created systems of law and, not least, advanced the dignity of the person
as a subject of inalienable rights.46 The Church, as the bearer of the Gospel, thus helped to spread and
consolidate those values which have made European culture universal.
With all this in mind, the Church of today, with a renewed sense of
responsibility, is conscious of the urgency of not squandering this precious
patrimony and of helping Europe to build herself by revitalizing her original
Showing the true face of Church
26. The entire Church in Europe ought to feel that the Lord's command and call
is addressed to her: examine yourself, be converted, “awake, and strengthen what
remains and is on the point of death” (Rev 3:2). The need to do so is
also born of a consideration of the present time: “The serious situation of
indifference towards religion on the part of so many Europeans, the presence of
many people even on our continent who do not yet know Jesus Christ and his
Church and who are not baptized, the secularism which poisons a wide spectrum of
Christians who habitually think, make decisions and live, 'as if Christ did not
exist', far from extinguishing our hope, make this hope more humble and more
able to trust in God alone. It is from his mercy that we receive the grace
and call to conversion”.48
27. Although at times, as in the Gospel episode of the calming of the tempest
(cf. Mk 4:35-41; Lk 8:22-25), it can appear that Christ is asleep
and leaves his barque to be tossed by the tumultuous waves, the Church in Europe
is called to grow in the certainty that the Lord, through the gift of his
Spirit, is ever present and at work in her midst and in all human history.
He prolongs his mission throughout time and makes the Church a stream of new
life coursing through the life of humanity as a sign of hope for all.
In a context where a temptation to activism is also attractive at the pastoral
level, Christians in Europe must continue to be a transparent image of the
Risen Christ, living in close communion with him.
There is a need for communities which, by contemplating and imitating the Virgin
Mary, the figure and model of the Church in faith and holiness,49 cultivate the sense of liturgical life and of interior life.
Before all and above all, they should praise the Lord, worship him and hear his
Word. Only in this way will they be able to partake of his mystery and live
totally in relation to him as members of his faithful Bride.
28. In the face of recurring impulses to division and opposition, the different
Particular Churches in Europe, strengthened also by their bond with the
Successor of Peter, must be committed to being a true locus and means of
communion for the whole People of God in faith and love.50 They should therefore foster a climate of fraternal charity, lived with
Gospel radicalism in the name of Jesus and in his love; they should create
cordial relationships, communication, shared responsibility and participation,
missionary consciousness, concern and readiness to serve. They should be
prompted by attitudes of esteem, acceptance and mutual correction (cf. Rom
12:10; 15:7-14), as well as of service and reciprocal support (cf. Gal
5:13; 6:2), mutual forgiveness (cf. Col 3:13), and mutual edification (cf. 1 Thes 5:11). They need to set
in place a pastoral programme which by maximizing all legitimate diversity would
also foster ready cooperation among individuals and groups. They need to
revitalize participatory bodies as valuable instruments of communion aimed at a
united missionary activity, and enabling the emergence of adequately trained and
qualified pastoral workers. In this way, the Churches themselves, enlivened by
the communion which is the manifestation of God's love, the ground and reason
for the hope which does not disappoint (cf. Rom 5:5), will be a more
brilliant reflection of the Trinity, as well as a challenging sign which invites
belief (cf. Jn 17:21).
29. If communion in the Church is to be experienced more fully, there is a need
to make the most of the variety of charisms and vocations which
increasingly converge on unity and can enrich it (cf. 1 Cor 12). In this regard,
the new movements and the new ecclesial communities must “abandon every
temptation to claim rights of primogeniture and every mutual incomprehension”,
advance along the path of more authentic communion between themselves and with
all other ecclesial realities, and “live with love in full obedience to the
Bishops”. But it is also necessary for the Bishops “to show them that fatherhood
and that love which are proper to Pastors”51 and to acknowledge, maximize and coordinate their charisms and their
presence for the building up of the one Church.
Thanks to an increase in cooperation between the different ecclesial bodies
under the loving leadership of their pastors, the whole Church will be able to
present to all a more beautiful and credible face, a clearer and more evident
reflection of the Lord's own face, and will then be able to give new hope and comfort both to those who seek her and to
those who, even though not seeking her, nonetheless need her.
In order to respond to the Gospel's call to conversion, “we must join in making
a humble and courageous examination of conscience, in order to
acknowledge our fears and our mistakes, sincerely confess our slowness to
believe, our omissions, our infidelities and our faults”.52 Far from fostering an attitude of hopelessness and discouragement, the
evangelical acknowledgment of one's sins will surely awaken within the community
the experience of each one of the baptized: the joy of profound liberation and
the grace of a new beginning which will enable it to set out with greater vigour
upon the path of evangelization.
Advancing towards Christian unity
30. Finally, the Gospel of hope is also a forceful summons to conversion in
the field of ecumenism. In the conviction that Christian unity corresponds
to the Lord's prayer “that they may all be one” (cf. Jn 17:11), and that
it is essential today for greater credibility in evangelization and the growth
of European unity, all the Churches and Ecclesial Communities need to “be
assisted and encouraged to see the journey of ecumenism as a 'travelling
together' towards Christ”53
and towards the visible unity which he wills, so that unity in diversity may
shine forth within the Church as a gift of the Holy Spirit, the builder of
If this is to happen, there is need for patient and persevering commitment on
the part of all, a commitment inspired both by genuine hope and sober realism,
aimed at “the enhancing of all that already unites us, sincere reciprocal
esteem, the elimination of prejudice, knowledge and mutual love”.54 Consequently, the pursuit of unity, in order to have a firm basis,
cannot fail to include the passionate search for truth through dialogue and
discussion which can acknowledge the progress already made and consider it an
incentive for even greater progress in resolving the disagreements which
continue to divide Christians.
31. Dialogue must continue with firm resolve, undaunted by difficulties
and hardship. It should be carried on “under different aspects (doctrinal,
spiritual and practical), following the logic of the exchange of gifts which the
Spirit awakens in every Church; it should train the community and the faithful,
and young people in particular, to experience moments of encounter and to make
ecumenism, rightly understood, an ordinary dimension of ecclesial life and
Such dialogue represents one of the chief concerns of the Church, especially in
this Europe, which in the last millennium witnessed the rise of all too many
divisions between Christians and which is today moving towards greater unity. We
may not halt on this journey nor may we turn back! We need to continue this
journey in a spirit of trust, so that mutual respect, the search for truth, cooperation in charity
and above all the ecumenism of holiness, will not fail, with God's help, to bear
32. Despite the inevitable difficulties, I ask everyone to acknowledge and
appreciate, in love and fraternity, the contribution which the Eastern
Catholic Churches can offer for a more genuine building up of unity
56 through their very presence, the richness of their tradition, the witness
of their “unity in diversity”, the inculturation which they have accomplished in
their proclamation of the Gospel, and the diversity of their rites. At the same
time I wish to assure once more the pastors and our brothers and sisters of the
Orthodox Churches that the new evangelization is in no way to be confused with
proselytism, without prejudice to the duty of respect for truth, for freedom and
for the dignity of every person.
II. The whole Church is sent on mission
33. Serving the Gospel of hope by means of a charity which evangelizes is the
commitment and the responsibility of everyone. Whatever the charism and
ministry of each individual, charity is the royal road prescribed for all and
which all can travel: it is the road upon which the whole ecclesial community is
called to journey in the footsteps of its Master.
The commitment of ordained ministers
34. In a special way priests are called by virtue of their ministry to
celebrate, teach and serve the Gospel of hope. Through the Sacrament of Orders
which configures them to Christ the Head and Shepherd, Bishops and priests must
conform their whole life and all their activity to Jesus. By the preaching of
the word, the celebration of the sacraments and their leadership of the
Christian community, they make present the mystery of Christ, and in the
exercise of their ministry “they are called to prolong the presence of Christ,
the One High Priest, embodying his way of life and making him visible in the
midst of the flock entrusted to their care”.57
As men who are “in” the world yet not “of” the world (cf. Jn 17:15-16),
priests are called in Europe's present cultural and spiritual situation to be a
sign of contradiction and of hope for a society suffering from “horizontalism”
and in need of openness to the Transcendent.
35. In this context priestly celibacy also stands out as the sign of hope
put totally in the Lord. Celibacy is not merely an ecclesiastical discipline
imposed by authority; rather it is first and foremost a grace, a priceless gift
of God for his Church, a prophetic value for the contemporary world, a source of
intense spiritual life and pastoral fruitfulness, a witness to the
eschatological Kingdom, a sign of God's love for this world, as well as a sign
of the priest's undivided love for God and for his people.58 Lived in response to God's gift and as a mastery of the temptations of a
hedonistic society, it not only leads to the human fulfilment of those who are
called to embrace it, but proves to be a source of growth for others as well.
Celibacy is esteemed in the whole Church as fitting for the priesthood,59 obligatory in the
Latin Church 60 and deeply respected by the Eastern Churches.61 In the present cultural context, it stands out as an eloquent sign which
needs to be cherished as a precious good for the Church. A revision of the
present discipline in this regard would not help to resolve the crisis of
vocations to the priesthood being felt in many parts of Europe.62 A commitment to the service of the Gospel of hope also demands
that the Church make every effort to propose celibacy in its full biblical,
theological and spiritual richness.
36. We cannot fail to see that the exercise of the sacred ministry today is
fraught with many difficulties on account of the prevailing culture and the
lessened numbers of priests, together with the increase of pastoral
responsibilities and the fatigue which this can involve. Consequently, all the
more esteem, gratitude and support is due to those priests
who carry out with praiseworthy dedication and fidelity the ministry which they
To these priests, making my own the words of the Synod Fathers, I also wish to
offer, with confidence and gratitude, my own encouragement:
“Do not lose heart and do not allow yourselves to be overcome with weariness! In
full communion with us Bishops, persevere in your invaluable and indispensable
ministry in joyful fraternity with your brother priests, in generous
collaboration with those in consecrated life and with all the lay faithful”.64
Together with priests I also wish to mention deacons, who share, albeit
to a different degree, in the one Sacrament of Holy Orders. Sent forth in
service to ecclesial communion, they exercise, under the leadership of the
Bishop and his presbyterate, the “diakonia” of liturgy, word and charity.65 In their own way, they are at the service of the Gospel of hope.
The witness of consecrated persons
37. Particularly eloquent is the witness of consecrated persons. In this
regard, acknowledgment must first be made of the fundamental role played by
monasticism and consecrated life in the evangelization of Europe and in the
shaping of its Christian identity.66 This role must continue to be played today, at a time when a “new
evangelization” of the continent is urgently needed and, with the creation of
more complex structures and relationships, it stands at a critical turning
point. Europe will always need the holiness, prophetic witness, evangelizing
activity and service of consecrated persons. Attention also needs to be paid to
the specific contribution which Secular Institutes and Societies of Apostolic
Life can make thanks to their aspiration to transform the world from within through
the power of the Beatitudes.
38. The specific contribution which consecrated persons can make to the
Gospel of hope takes as its starting-point several characteristics of the
present-day cultural and social face of Europe.67 The demand for new forms of spirituality, now making itself felt
throughout society, needs to find a response in the acknowledgment of God's
absolute primacy which consecrated persons experience in their total gift of
self and their permanent conversion in a life offered up as true spiritual
worship. In an atmosphere poisoned by secularism and dominated by consumerism,
consecrated life, as a gift of the Spirit to the Church and for the Church,
becomes an ever greater sign of hope to the extent that it testifies to life's
transcendent dimension. In today's multicultural and multireligious world, there
is also a demand for the witness of that evangelical fraternity which
characterizes the consecrated life and makes it a stimulus to purifying and
integrating different values through the reconciliation of divisions. The
presence of new forms of poverty and marginalization ought to call forth that
creativity in the care of those most in need which has marked so many
founders of Religious Institutes. Finally, the tendency to a certain
self-absorption can find an antidote in the readiness of consecrated persons to
continue the work of evangelization on other continents, despite the
decrease of numbers in various Institutes.
Concern for vocations
39. Since the commitment of ordained ministers and consecrated persons is
decisive, some mention must be made of the disturbing shortage of seminarians
and aspirants to religious life, especially in Western Europe. This situation
calls for everyone to be involved in an effective pastoral programme of
promoting vocations. “Whenever the person of Jesus Christ is presented
clearly to young people, he inspires in them a hope that motivates them to
abandon everything in order to follow him in response to his call, and to bear
witness to him among their peers”.68 The pastoral care of vocations is thus a vital issue for the future of
the Christian faith in Europe and, in turn, for the spiritual advancement of the
very peoples who inhabit the continent. It is a challenge which must be met by a
Church which wishes to proclaim, celebrate and serve the Gospel of hope.69
40. To create a much-needed pastoral programme of promoting vocations, it is
beneficial to explain to the laity the Church's faith regarding the nature and
dignity of the ministerial priesthood; to encourage families to live as true
“domestic churches”, so that in their midst the variety of vocations can be
discerned, accepted and nurtured; and to engage in pastoral work aimed at
helping young people in particular to choose a life rooted in Christ and
completely dedicated to the Church.70
In the certainty that the Holy Spirit is still at work today, and that the signs
of his presence are not lacking, it is mainly a question of making the
promotion of vocations a part of ordinary pastoral care. There is a need “to
rekindle a deep yearning for God, especially in young people, thus creating a
suitable context in which generous vocational responses can be made”; it is
urgent that a great movement of prayer spread across the ecclesial Communities
of the European continent, since “changed historical and cultural situations
demand that the pastoral care of vocations be perceived as one of the primary
objectives of the entire Christian community”.71 It is also indispensable for priests themselves to live and work in a way
consistent with their true sacramental identity. For if the image they project
is unclear or indifferent, how can they attract young people to imitate them?
The mission of the laity
41. The contribution of the lay faithful to the life of the Church is
essential: they have an irreplaceable role in the proclamation and the service
of the Gospel of hope, since “through them the Church of Christ is made present
in the various sectors of the world, as a sign and source of hope and of love”.72 As full sharers in the Church's mission in the world, they are called to
testify that the Christian faith constitutes the only complete response to the
questions which life sets before every individual and every society, and they
are able to imbue the world with the values of the Kingdom of God, the promise
and guarantee of a hope which does not disappoint.
Europe yesterday and today has experienced the presence of important and
illustrious examples of such lay persons. As the Synod Fathers emphasized,
grateful mention must be made especially of those men and women who have and who
continue to bear witness to Christ and his Gospel by their service to public
life and the responsibilities which this entails. It is supremely important “to
prompt and sustain specific vocations to serve the common good: persons who
after the example and manner of many so-called 'Fathers of Europe' can be
builders of tomorrow's European society, establishing it a on a firm spiritual
Equal esteem is due to the work carried out by Christian lay persons, often in
the hidden- ness of daily life, through humble acts of service capable of
proclaiming God's mercy to the poor; we must be grateful to these men and women
for their fearless witness of charity and forgiveness, values which bring the
Gospel to the vast frontiers of politics, social life, the economy, culture,
ecology, international life, family life, education, professional life, the
world of labour and the caring professions.74 This calls for programmes of training capable of preparing suitable
lay persons to apply their faith in temporal affairs. These programmes, based on
a serious introduction to the Church's life and particularly the study of her
social doctrine, ought to be able to provide them not only with teaching and
encouragement, but also with adequate grounding in spirituality in order to
strengthen their commitment, lived as an authentic path to holiness.
The role of women
42. The Church is very much aware of the specific contribution of women
in service of the Gospel of hope. The history of the Christian community
demonstrates that women have always had an outstanding place in bearing witness
to the Gospel. Mention must be made of how much they have done, often in silence
and obscurity, to receive and pass on the gift of God through physical and
spiritual motherhood, education, catechesis, the accomplishment of great
charitable works, through the life of prayer and contemplation, and through
mystical experiences and writings rich in the wisdom of the Gospel.75
In the light of their splendid and powerful witness in the past, the Church
expresses her confidence in all that women are capable of doing today for
the growth of hope at every level. There are aspects of contemporary European
society which represent a challenge for women's capacity to receive, share
and bring to birth in love, with determination and generosity. One thinks,
for example, of the prevalent scientific and technical mind-set which eclipses
the areas of affectivity and emotional life, the lack of generosity, the
widespread fear of giving life to new children, the difficulty of relating
with others and of accepting those who are different. It is in this context
that the Church looks to women for the life-giving contribution of a new
wave of hope.
43. For this to happen, however, the dignity of women must be promoted above all
in the Church, inasmuch as woman and man enjoy equal dignity, for both
have been created in the image and likeness of God (cf. Gen 1:27) and
each has been given proper and specific gifts.
It is to be hoped, as the Synod emphasized, that the full participation of women
in the Church's life and mission will be fostered by making better use of their
gifts and by entrusting them with ecclesial roles reserved by law to laypersons.
There must also be a due appreciation of women's mission as wives and mothers
and their dedication to family life.76
The Church has not failed to raise her voice in denunciation of injustice and
the violence perpetrated against women wherever and however this occurs. She
demands that laws protecting women be enforced, and that effective measures be
taken against the demeaning portrayal of women in advertising and against the
scourge of prostitution. She also expresses the hope that the domestic work done
by mothers will be considered, like that of fathers, as a contribution to the
common good, even through forms of financial retribution.
PROCLAIMING THE GOSPEL OF HOPE
“Go, take the scroll which is open ... take it and eat”
Proclaiming the mystery of Christ
Revelation gives meaning to history
44. The vision of the Book of Revelation tells us of “a scroll written within
and on the back, sealed with seven seals” and held “in the right hand of him who
was seated on the throne” (Rev 5:1). This writing contains the God's plan
of creation and salvation, his detailed design for all things, for persons,
things and events. No created being, on earth or in heaven, is able to “open the
scroll or to look into it” (Rev 5:3) so as to understand its contents. In
the confusion of human affairs, no one is able to declare the unfolding of
the future and the ultimate meaning of things.
Only Jesus Christ gains possession of the sealed scroll (cf. Rev 5:6-7);
only he is “worthy to take the scroll and open its seals” (Rev 5:9).
Only Jesus is able to reveal and bring about the plan of God hidden therein.
Left to himself, man is not capable of giving meaning to history and to human affairs: life remains without
hope. Only the Son of God is able to dispel the shadows and to show the way.
The open scroll is given to John and, through him, to the whole Church. John is told to take
the book and to eat it: “Go, take the scroll which is open in the hand of the
angel who is standing on the sea and on the land ... take it and eat it” (Rev
10:8-9). Only when he has assimilated it deeply will he be able to communicate
it properly to others, to whom he is sent with the order to “prophesy about many
peoples and nations and tongues and kings” (Rev 10:11).
The urgent need for proclamation
45. The Gospel of hope, received and assimilated by the Church, calls for daily
proclamation and witness. This is the proper vocation of the Church in every
time and place. It is also the mission of the Church in Europe today. For
“evangelizing is the grace and vocation proper to the Church, her deepest
identity. The Church exists in order to evangelize, that is to say in order to
preach and teach, to be the channel of the gift of grace, to reconcile sinners
with God, and to perpetuate Christ's sacrifice in the Mass, which is the
memorial of his death and glorious Resurrection”.77
Church in Europe, the “new evangelization” is the task set before you! Rediscover the enthusiasm
of proclamation. Hear today, addressed to you at the beginning of this third millennium, the plea heard at the beginning
of the first millennium, when a man of Macedonia appeared in a vision to Paul
and begged him: “Come over to Macedonia and help us!” (Acts 16:9). Even
if it remains unexpressed or even repressed, this is the most profound and
genuine plea rising from the hearts of Europeans today, who yearn for a hope
which does not disappoint. This hope has been bestowed on you as a gift which
must then be joyfully given away in every time and place. Let the
proclamation of Jesus, which is the Gospel of hope, be your boast and
your whole life. Carry on with renewed zeal in the same missionary spirit
which, down these twenty centuries, beginning with the preaching of the Apostles
Peter and Paul, has inspired so many holy men and women, the Saints who were
authentic evangelizers of the European continent.
A first proclamation and a renewed proclamation
46. In various parts of Europe a first proclamation of the Gospel is needed:
the number of the unbaptized is growing, both because of the significant
presence of immigrants of other religions and because children born into
families of Christian tradition have not received Baptism, either as a result of
the Communist domination or the spread of religious indifference.78
Indeed, Europe is now one of those traditionally Christian places which,
in addition to a new evangelization, require in some cases a first
The Church cannot shirk the responsibility of making a courageous diagnosis
which will make it possible to decide on appropriate therapies. On the “old”
continent too, there are vast social and cultural areas which stand in need of a
true missio ad gentes.79
47. Everywhere, then, a renewed proclamation is needed even for those already
baptized. Many Europeans today think they know what Christianity is, yet
they do not really know it at all. Often they are lacking in knowledge of the
most basic elements and notions of the faith. Many of the baptized live as if
Christ did not exist: the gestures and signs of faith are repeated, especially
in devotional practices, but they fail to correspond to a real acceptance of the
content of the faith and fidelity to the person of Jesus. The great certainties
of the faith are being undermined in many people by a vague religiosity lacking
real commitment; various forms of agnosticism and practical atheism are
spreading and serve to widen the division between faith and life; some people
have been affected by the spirit of an immanentist humanism, which has weakened
the faith and often, tragically, led to its complete abandonment; one encounters
a sort of secularist interpretation of Christian faith which is corrosive and
accompanied by a deep crisis of conscience and of Christian moral practice.80 The great values which amply inspired European culture have been separated
from the Gospel, thus losing their very soul and paving the way for any number
“When the Son of man comes, will he find faith on earth?” (Lk 18:8). Will
he find faith in our countries, in this Europe of ancient Christian tradition?
This is an open question which clearly reveals the depth and the drama of one of
the most serious challenges which our Churches are called to face. It can be
said as the Synod emphasized that this challenge frequently consists not so much
in baptizing new converts as in enabling those already baptized to be
converted to Christ and his Gospel: 81 in our communities we need to be seriously concerned about bringing the
Gospel of hope to all those who are far from the faith or who have abandoned the
practice of Christianity.
Fidelity to the one message
48. Proclaiming the Gospel of hope calls for steadfast fidelity to the Gospel
itself. The Church's preaching, in all its forms, must be
increasingly centred on the person of Jesus and increasingly converge on
him. Vigilant care must be taken that Christ is presented in his fullness:
not merely as an ethical model, but above all as the Son of God, the one,
necessary Saviour of all, who lives and is at work in his Church. If our hope is
to be true and unshakable, “an integral, clear and renewed preaching of the
Risen Christ, the resurrection and eternal life” 82 must be a priority for pastoral activity in coming years.
Although the Gospel to be preached is the same in every time, this preaching
can be carried out in different ways. All are called to “proclaim” Jesus and
their faith in him in every situation; to “draw” others to the faith through
models of personal, family, professional and community life which reflect the
Gospel; “to radiate” joy, love and hope, so that many people, seeing our good
works, will give glory to our Father in heaven (cf. Mt 5:16) and be won
over; to become “a leaven” transforming and enlivening from within every
expression of culture.83
By the witness of life
49. Europe calls out for credible evangelizers, whose lives, in communion
with the Cross and Resurrection of Christ, radiate the beauty of the Gospel.84 Such evangelizers must be properly trained.85 Now more than ever a missionary consciousness
is needed in all Christians, beginning with Bishops, priests, deacons,
consecrated persons, catechists and teachers of religion: “All the baptized, since they are
witnesses of Christ, should receive a training appropriate to their
circumstances, not only so that their faith does not wither for lack of care in
a hostile environment such as the secularist world, but also so that their
witness to the Gospel will receive strength and inspiration”.86
Our contemporaries “listen more willingly to witnesses than to teachers, and if
they do listen to teachers, it is because they are witnesses”.87 The presence and the signs of holiness are thus decisive:
holiness is the essential prerequisite for an authentic evangelization
capable of reviving hope. What is needed are forceful, personal and communal
testimonies of new life in Christ. It is not enough that truth and grace are
offered through the proclamation of the word and the celebration of the
sacraments; they need to be accepted and experienced in every practical
situation, in the way Christians and ecclesial communities lead their lives.
This is one of the greatest challenges set before the Church in Europe at the
beginning of the new millennium.
Training for an adult faith
50. “Europe's cultural and religious situation today calls for the presence of
Catholics who are adult in their faith and for missionary Christian communities
who testify to God's love before all mankind”.88 The proclamation of the Gospel of hope thus implies a concern to foster
the movement from a faith supported by social tradition, important as this
is, to a more personal and adult faith, one marked by knowledge and
Christians are therefore “called to have a faith capable of critically
confronting contemporary culture and resisting its enticements; of having an
real effect on the world of culture, finance, society and politics; of
demonstrating that the fellowship between Catholics and other Christians is more
powerful than any ethnic bond; of joyfully passing on the faith to new generations; and of building a
Christian culture ready to evangelize the larger culture in which we live”.89
51. Along with ensuring that the ministry of the word, the celebration of the
liturgy and the exercise of charity are directed to building up and sustaining a
mature and personal faith, Christian communities need to work at proposing a
catechesis adapted to the varying spiritual journeys of the faithful at
different ages and in different life situations, and to provide for suitable
programmes for spiritual accompaniment and for the rediscovery of one's own
Baptism.90 Naturally a fundamental point of reference in this commitment will be the
Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Given its undeniable priority in pastoral activity, there is a particular need
to cultivate and, if need be, reinstitute the ministry of catechesis
as a means of education and faith development for each individual, so that
the seed planted by the Holy Spirit and passed on by Baptism can grow and reach
maturity. In constant reference to the word of God, preserved in sacred
Scripture, proclaimed in the liturgy and interpreted by the Church's Tradition,
an organic and systematic catechesis constitutes beyond the shadow of a doubt an
essential and primary means of forming Christians in an adult faith.91
52. In this same context, the important task of theology must also be
emphasized. There is an intrinsic and inseparable link between evangelization and theological reflection, since
theology, as a science possessed of a proper status and methodology, draws its
life from the Church's faith and stands at the service of her mission.92 Theology is born of faith and is called to interpret faith, preserving its
unbreakable link to the Christian community in all its different forms; as a
service to the spiritual growth of all the faithful,93 it introduces them to a deeper understanding of the message of Christ.
In carrying out her mission of proclaiming the Gospel of hope, the Church in
Europe expresses esteem and gratitude for the vocation of theologians,
she values them and supports their work.94 With respect and affection I encourage theologians to persevere in the
service which they render, to combine their scholarly research with prayer, to
engage in attentive dialogue with contemporary culture, to adhere faithfully to
the Magisterium and to cooperate with it in a spirit of communion in truth and
charity, immersed in the sensus fidei of the People of God and helping to
II. Bearing witness in unity and dialogue
Communion between the Particular Churches
53. The power of the proclamation of the Gospel of hope will be all the more
effective if it is linked to the witness of a profound unity and communion in
the Church. The individual Particular Churches cannot face alone the challenge before them. There is need for
genuine cooperation between all the Particular Churches of the Continent as
an expression of their essential communion; a cooperation which is also
called for by the new reality of Europe.95 Here mention must be made of the contribution offered by continental
ecclesial bodies, beginning with the Council of European Episcopal
Conferences. The Council is an effective means for exploring together
appropriate ways of evangelizing Europe.96 Through an “exchange of gifts” between the various Particular Churches,
the experiences and the reflections of Western and Eastern, Northern and
Southern Europe are shared and common pastoral approaches emerge. The Council is
becoming an increasingly significant expression of the collegial sentiment
linking the Bishops of the Continent, aimed at proclaiming together, boldly and
faithfully, the name of Jesus Christ, the sole source of hope for everyone in
Together with all Christians
54. The duty of fraternal and committed ecumenical cooperation also
emerges as an irrevocable imperative.
The future of evangelization is closely linked to the witness of unity given by
all Christ's followers: “All Christians are called to carry out this mission in
accordance with their vocation. The task of evangelization involves moving
towards one another and moving forward together as Christians, and it must begin from within; evangelization and unity,
evangelization and ecumenism are indissolubly linked”.97 Therefore I once again make my own the words written by Paul VI to
Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I: “May the Holy Spirit guide us along the way
of reconciliation, so that the unity of our Churches may become an ever more
radiant sign of hope and consolation for all mankind”.98
In dialogue with other religions
55. As is the case with the overall commitment to the “new evangelization”, so
too proclaiming the Gospel of hope calls for the establishment of a profound and
perceptive interreligious dialogue, particularly with Judaism and with
Islam. “Understood as a method and means of mutual knowledge and enrichment,
dialogue is not in opposition to the mission ad gentes; indeed, it has
special links with that mission and is one of its expressions”.99 Engagement in this dialogue must avoid yielding to a “widespread
indifferentism, which sad to say, is found also among Christians. It is often
based on incorrect theological perspectives and is characterized by a
religious relativism which leads to the belief that 'one religion is as good as
56. It is rather a matter of being more vividly aware of the relationship
which binds the Church to the Jewish people
and of Israel's unique role in salvation history. As was already clear from
the First Special Assembly for Europe of the Synod of Bishops, and was reaffirmed
in the latest Synod, there is need for acknowledgment of the common roots
linking Christianity and the Jewish people, who are called by God to a covenant
which remains irrevocable (cf. Rom 11:29) 101 and has attained definitive fullness in Christ.
Consequently it is necessary to encourage dialogue with Judaism, knowing that it
is fundamentally important for the self-knowledge of Christians and for the
transcending of divisions between the Churches, and to work for the flowering of
a new springtime in mutual relations. This demands that each ecclesial community
engage, to the extent that circumstances permit, in dialogue and cooperation
with believers of the Jewish religion. This engagement also implies that
“acknowledgment be given to any part which the children of the Church have had
in the growth and spread of antisemitism in history; forgiveness must be sought
for this from God, and every effort must be made to favour encounters of
reconciliation and of friendship with the sons of Israel”.102
It will likewise be appropriate to mention the many Christians who,
sometimes at the cost of their lives, helped and saved, especially in times of
persecution, these their “elder brethren”.
57. It is also a question of growing in knowledge of other religions, in order
to establish a fraternal conversation with their members who live in today's
Europe. A proper relationship with Islam is particularly important. As has often become evident in recent years to the
Bishops of Europe, this “needs to be conducted prudently, with clear ideas about
possibilities and limits, and with confidence in God's saving plan for all his
children”.103 It is also necessary to take into account the notable gap between European
culture, with its profound Christian roots, and Muslim thought.104
In this regard, Christians living in daily contact with Muslims should be
properly trained in an objective knowledge of Islam and enabled to draw
comparisons with their own faith. Such training should be provided particularly
to seminarians, priests and all pastoral workers. It is on the other hand
understandable that the Church, even as she asks the European institutions to
ensure the promotion of religious freedom in Europe, should feel the need to
insist that reciprocity in guaranteeing religious freedom also be observed in
countries of different religious traditions, where Christians are a minority.105
In this context, “one can understand the astonishment and the feeling of
frustration of Christians who welcome, for example in Europe, believers of other
religions, giving them the possibility of exercising their worship, and who see
themselves forbidden all exercise of Christian worship”106 in
countries where those believers are in the majority and have made their own
religion the only one admitted and promoted. The human person has a right
to religious freedom, and all people, in every part of the world, “should
be immune from coercion on the part of individuals, social groups and every
III. Evangelizing the life of society
The evangelization of culture and the inculturation of the Gospel
58. The proclamation of Jesus Christ must also reach contemporary European
culture. The evangelization of culture must show that in today's Europe
too it is possible to live the Gospel fully as a path which gives meaning to
existence. To this end, pastoral practice must undertake the task of shaping a
Christian mentality in ordinary life: in families, in schools, in social
communications, in cultural life, in the workplace and the economy, in politics,
in leisure-time, in health and in sickness. What is needed is a calm critical
assessment of the current cultural situation of Europe and an evaluation of the
emerging trends and the more significant contemporary events and situations in
the light of the centrality of Christ and of Christian anthropology.
Today too, in recalling Christianity's contributions to culture throughout the
history of Europe, there is a need to demonstrate the Gospel approach, both
theoretical and practical, to reality and to man himself. Furthermore,
considering the great importance of the sciences and technological achievements
in European culture and society, the Church, through both her institutes of
study and in her practical pastoral initiatives, is called to be constructive in
her approach to scientific knowledge and its applications, pointing out the
insufficiency and inadequacy of notions inspired by a scientism which recognizes only experimental knowledge
as objectively valid, and presenting ethical criteria which man possesses as
inscribed in his very nature.108
59. An important part of any programme for the evangelization of culture is the
service rendered by Catholic schools. There is a need to ensure the
recognition of a genuine freedom of education and equal juridical standing
between state schools and other schools. Catholic schools are sometimes the sole
means by which the Christian tradition can be presented to those who are distant
from it. I encourage the faithful involved in the field of primary and
secondary education to persevere in their mission and to bring the light of
Christ the Saviour to bear upon their specific educational, scientific and
academic activities.109 In particular, greater recognition is due to the contribution made by
Christians who conduct research and teach in universities: in their
“service to thought” they hand down to the next generation the values of an
intellectual tradition enriched by two thousand years of humanistic and
Christian experience. Convinced of the importance of academic institutions, I
also ask the various local Churches to promote an adequate pastoral care of
the university community, favouring whatever corresponds to present cultural
60. Nor should we overlook the positive contribution made by the wise use of the
cultural treasures of the Church. These can be a special element in the rekindling of a humanism of
Christian inspiration. When properly preserved and intelligently used, these
living testimonies of the faith as professed down the ages can prove a useful
resource for the new evangelization and for catechesis, and lead to a
rediscovery of the sense of mystery.
At the same time new artistic expressions of the faith should be promoted
through a constant dialogue with those engaged in the arts.111 The Church in fact needs art, literature, music, painting, sculpture and
architecture, because she “must make perceptible, and as far as possible
attractive, the world of the spirit, of the invisible, of God”,112 and because artistic beauty, as a sort of echo of the Spirit of God, is a
symbol pointing to the mystery, an invitation to seek out the face of God made
visible in Jesus of Nazareth.
Training young people in the faith
61. I encourage the Church in Europe to give greater attention to the
training of young people in the faith. As we look to the future, we cannot
but think of them: we need to make contact with the minds, the hearts and the
character of the young in order to provide them with a sound human and Christian
Wherever many young people are present, it is hard not to perceive the wide
variety of their attitudes and approaches. We can see their desire to be
together and to come out of their isolation, and their thirst, recognized in differing degrees, for the absolute; we see in
them a secret faith needing to be purified and desirous of following the Lord;
we become aware of their decision to continue the journey already begun and the
need to share their faith.
62. To this end, there is need for a renewed youth ministry, organized by
age groups and attentive to the varying situations of children, adolescents and
young adults. It will also be necessary to provide this ministry with a more
organic structure and consistency, and to be patiently concerned with the
questions raised by young people, in order to make them protagonists of the
evangelization and the building of society.
In this process opportunities should be provided for encounter among young
people, so as to foster a climate of mutual listening and prayer. There is no
need to fear making demands upon them with regard to their spiritual growth. The
way of holiness should be pointed out to them and they should be encouraged to
make demanding choices in their following of Jesus, drawing their strength from
an intense sacramental life. In this way they will learn to resist the
enticements of a culture which often proposes values which are merely
superficial or even contrary to the Gospel, and become capable of demonstrating
a Christian approach to every sphere of human life, including entertainment and
I can still see clearly the joyful faces of so many young people, the
true hope of the Church and of the world and an eloquent sign of the Spirit who unceasingly causes new energies to
arise. I have met them during my travels to various countries and during the
unforgettable World Youth Days.114
Attention to the mass media
63. Given the importance of the means of social communication, the Church in
Europe must necessarily pay particular attention to the multi-faceted world
of the mass media. This would include, among other things: the adequate
training of Christians who work in the field of communications and of those who
make use of the media, for a better understanding of the new kinds of language
employed in the media. Special attention should be given to choosing properly
trained persons to communicate the message through the media. It would also
prove very helpful to have an exchange of information and of strategies between
the Churches about different aspects and initiatives concerning this
communication. Nor should the creation of local instruments of social
communications be neglected, also on the parish level.
At the same time, it is a matter of becoming involved in the processes of social
communications, in order to make them more respectful of the truth of
information and of the dignity of the human person. In this regard, I invite
Catholics to contribute to the establishment of a code of ethics for those who
work in the field of social communications, letting themselves be guided by the
criteria which the competent agencies of the Holy See have recently indicated,115 and which the Bishops in Synod have listed as follows: “respect for the
dignity of the human person, for his or her rights, including the right of
privacy; service to truth, to justice and to human, cultural and spiritual
values; respect for diverse cultures to avoid their disappearance within the
majority, protection of minority groups and of the weak; pursuit of the common
good, over and above particular interests and the predominance of economic
The mission “ad gentes”
64. A proclamation of Jesus Christ and his Gospel limited to the European
context alone would betray symptoms of a disturbing lack of hope. The work of
evangelization is animated by true Christian hope when it is open to universal
horizons, which lead us to offer freely to all what we ourselves have received
as gift. In this way the mission ad gentes becomes an expression of a
Church shaped by the Gospel of hope, which is continually renewed and
rejuvenated. Down the centuries this has been part of the self-awareness of the
Church in Europe: countless hosts of missionaries, going forth to meet other
races and other civilizations, have proclaimed the Gospel of Jesus Christ to the
peoples of the whole world.
The same missionary ardour must animate the Church in Europe today. The decrease in the numbers of priests and of consecrated men and women in
some countries must not prevent any Particular Church from making its own the needs of the universal Church. Every
Church will find a way to prepare its faithful for the mission ad gentes,
and thus respond with generosity to the appeal of many peoples and nations which
desire to know the Gospel. The Churches of other continents, particularly Asia
and Africa, still look to the Churches in Europe and expect them to continue to
carry out their missionary vocation. Christians in Europe cannot be unfaithful
to their own history.117
The Gospel: a book for the Europe of today and tomorrow
65. As I stepped through the Holy Door at the beginning of the Great Jubilee of
the Year 2000, I held high the Book of the Gospels, showing it to the Church and
to the world. This same ritual action, carried out by all the Bishops in the
different cathedrals of the world, points to the task awaiting the Church of our
Continent now and for ever.
Church in Europe, enter the new millennium with the Book of the Gospels! May every member of the faithful hear the Council's plea “to learn 'the
surpassing knowledge of Jesus Christ' (Phil 3:8) by frequent reading of
the divine Scriptures. 'Ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ' ”.118
May the Holy Bible continue to be a treasure for the Church and for every
Christian: in the careful study of God's word we will daily find nourishment and
strength to carry out our mission.
Let us take up this book! Let us receive it from the Lord who continually offers
it to us through his Church (cf. Rev 10:8). Let us devour it (cf.
Rev 10:9), so that it can become our very life. Let us savour it
deeply: it will make demands of us, but it will give us joy because it is sweet
as honey (cf. Rev 10:9-10). Filled with hope, we will be able to share
it with every man and woman whom we encounter on our way.
CELEBRATING THE GOSPEL OF HOPE
“To him who sits upon the throne and to the Lamb be blessing and honour and glory and might
for ever and ever!” (Rev 5:13)
A community of prayer
66. The Gospel of hope, as a proclamation of the truth which sets us free
(cf. Jn 8:32) is meant to be celebrated. Before the Lamb of the
Book of Revelation there begins a solemn liturgy of praise and adoration: “To
him who sits upon the throne and to the Lamb be blessing and honour and glory
and might for ever and ever!” (Rev 5:13). This vision, which reveals both God and the meaning of all history,
takes place “on the Lord's day” (Rev 1:10), the day of the resurrection, as re- lived by the Sunday assembly.
The Church which receives this revelation is a community of prayer. In her
prayer she listens to her Lord and hears what the Spirit is saying to
her. She worships, gives praise, offers thanks, and ends by imploring the coming
of the Lord: “Come, Lord Jesus!” (Rev 22:16-20). She thus declares that
salvation comes from him alone.
Church of God dwelling in Europe, you too are called to be a community which
prays, celebrating your Lord in the Sacraments, in the liturgy and in your whole
life. In prayer you will discover the Lord's life-giving presence. By making him
the foundation of all your activity, you will thus be able to invite Europeans
to an encounter with him, our true hope, the One who alone knows how to satisfy
fully the yearning for God hidden in the different forms of religious quest now
reappearing in contemporary Europe.
I. Rediscovering the Liturgy
The religious sense in today's Europe
67. Despite the dechristianization of vast areas of the European Continent,
there are signs which suggest an image of a Church which, in
believing, proclaims, celebrates and serves her Lord. Indeed examples are
not lacking of authentic Christians who experience contemplative silence,
faithfully take part in spiritual activities, live the Gospel in their daily
lives and bear witness to it in the different settings in which they are
involved. Moreover, we can discern examples of a “popular holiness” which
indicate that in contemporary Europe too it is not impossible to live the Gospel
individually and in an authentic community experience.
68. Together with the many examples of genuine faith, there also exists in
Europe a vague and at times deviant religiosity. Its signs are often
generic and superficial, or even contradictory, in the very persons who manifest them.
There are evident signs of a flight to spiritualism, of religious and esoteric
syncretism, of a frantic search for extraordinary events, even to the point of
making aberrant decisions, such as joining dangerous sects or engaging in
The widespread desire for spiritual nourishment needs to be accepted with
understanding and purified. To the person who becomes aware, even if in a
confused way, of not being able to live by bread alone, the Church must be able
to give convincing witness to the words which Jesus spoke to the tempter: “Man
shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of
God” (Mt 4:4).
A Church which celebrates
69. In the context of today's society, often closed to transcendence,
oppressed by consumeristic behaviour, easily falling prey to old and new forms of
idolatry yet at the same time thirsting for something which goes beyond the
immediate, the task that awaits the Church in Europe is both demanding
and exciting. It consists in rediscovering the sense of “mystery”; in renewing
liturgical celebrations so that they can be more eloquent signs of the presence
of Christ the Lord; in ensuring greater silence in prayer and in contemplation;
in returning to the Sacraments, especially the Eucharist and Penance, as
wellsprings of freedom and new hope.
For this reason, I urgently invite you, the Church living in Europe: be a Church that prays, praises God, recognising his absolute primacy,
magnifying him with joyful faith. Rediscover the sense of mystery: live
it with humble gratitude; testify to it with conviction and contagious joy.
Celebrate the salvation which comes from Christ: welcome it as a gift which
makes of you its sacrament; make your life a true spiritual worship pleasing to
God (cf. Rom 12:1).
The sense of mystery
70. Certain signs point to a weakening in the sense of mystery in the very
liturgical celebrations which should be fostering that sense. It is, therefore,
urgent that the authentic sense of the liturgy be revived in the Church. The
liturgy, as the Synod Fathers noted,119 is a means of sanctification; it is a celebration of the Church's
faith, and a means of transmitting the faith. Together with Sacred Scripture and
the teachings of the Fathers of the Church, it is a living source of authentic
and sound spirituality. As the tradition of the venerable Eastern Churches also
clearly emphasizes, it is through the liturgy that the faithful enter into
communion with the Most Holy Trinity and experience their sharing in the divine
nature as a gift of grace. In this way the liturgy becomes a foretaste of final
blessedness and a sharing in the glory of heaven.
71. Liturgical celebrations need once more to put Jesus at the centre, so that
we can be enlightened and guided by him. Here we can find one of the most
forceful responses which our communities are called to make in the face of any
kind of vague or inconsistent religiosity. The purpose of the liturgy of the
Church is not to placate people's desires or fears, but to hear and receive the
living Jesus, who honours and praises the Father, in order that we may praise
and honour the Father with him. The Church's celebrations proclaim that our hope
comes to us from God through Jesus our Lord.
This involves experiencing the liturgy as a work of the Trinity. It is
the Father who acts for us in the mysteries being celebrated; it is he who
speaks to us, forgives us, listens to us and gives us his Spirit; it is to him
that we turn, it is he whom we hear, praise and invoke. It is Jesus who effects
our sanctification by making us sharers in his mystery. It is the Holy Spirit
who by the working of his grace makes us the Body of Christ, the Church.
The Liturgy must be lived as proclamation and anticipation of our future
glory, the ultimate goal of our hope. As the Council teaches, “in the
earthly liturgy we take part in a foretaste of that heavenly liturgy which is
celebrated in the Holy City of Jerusalem towards which we journey as pilgrims,
until Christ our life will appear and we too will appear with him in glory”.120
72. Although in the period following the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council real
progress has been made towards experiencing the authentic meaning of the
liturgy, much remains to be done. Continual renewal and constant training are
needed for everyone: the ordained, consecrated persons and the laity.
True renewal, far from depending on arbitrary actions, consists of
constantly developing an awareness of the sense of mystery, in order to create
liturgical moments of communion with the great and holy mystery of the Trinity.
By celebrating the sacred actions as a relationship with God and an acceptance
of his gifts, the expression of an authentic spiritual life, the Church in
Europe will truly be able to nourish her hope and offer that hope to those who
have lost it.
73. To this end a great effort of education is needed. Aimed at fostering
an understanding of the true meaning of the Church's liturgical celebrations, it
requires, in addition to an adequate instruction in the rites, an authentic
spirituality and formation in experiencing those celebrations fully.121 Consequently an authentically “liturgical mystagogy” needs to be better
promoted, with the active participation of all the faithful – each
according to his or her proper role – in the sacred mysteries, and especially the
II. Celebrating the Sacraments
74. A prominent place need to be given to the celebration of the sacraments,
as actions of Christ and of the Church ordered to the worship of God, to the
sanctification of people and to the building up of the ecclesial community. In
the knowledge that in them Christ himself is acting through the Holy Spirit, the
sacraments should celebrated with the greatest care and under appropriate
conditions. The Particular Churches on the continent will have to make efforts
to strengthen their pastoral practice with regard to the sacraments so that
their deepest reality is understood. The Synod Fathers have stressed the need
for this in order to respond to two dangers: on the one hand, certain sectors of
the Church seem to have lost sight of the genuine meaning of the sacraments and
might trivialize the mysteries being celebrated; while on the other hand, many
of the baptized, following customs and traditional practices, continue to have
recourse to the Sacraments at significant moments of their life, yet do not live
in accordance with the Church's teaching.122
75. The Eucharist, the greatest gift of Christ to the Church, makes
present in mystery the sacrifice of Christ offered for our salvation: “in the
most blessed Eucharist is contained the whole spiritual good of the Church,
namely Christ himself, our Pasch”.123 The pilgrim Church draws sustenance from the Eucharist, “the source and
summit of the Christian life”,124 and finds there the source of all her hope. The Eucharist in fact “spurs
us on our journey through history and plants a seed of living hope in our daily
commitment to the work before us”.125
We are all invited to profess faith in the Eucharist, “the pledge of
future glory”, in the certainty that the communion with Christ now experienced
by pilgrims in their mortal lives is a foretaste of their ultimate encounter
with him on that day when “we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is”
(1 Jn 3:2). The Eucharist is a “taste of eternity within time”, it is
God's presence and our communion with that presence; as the memorial of Christ's
Passover, it is by its very nature a bearer of grace within human history. It
opens us to the future of God; as communion with Christ, with his body and
blood, it is a sharing in God's own eternal life.126
76. Along with the Eucharist, the Sacrament of Reconciliation must also
exercise a fundamental role in the recovery of hope: “a personal
experience of the forgiveness of God for each one of us is, in fact, the
essential foundation of every hope for our future”.127 One of the roots of the hopelessness that assails many people today is
found in their inability to see themselves as sinners and to allow themselves to
be forgiven, an inability often resulting from the isolation of those who, by
living as if God did not exist, have no one from whom they can seek forgiveness.
Those who, on the other hand, acknowledge that they are sinners, and entrust
themselves to the mercy of the Heavenly Father, experience the joy of an
authentic liberation and can continue life without being trapped in their own
misery.128 In this way they receive the grace of a new beginning, and again
find reasons for hope.
For this reason the Sacrament of Reconciliation needs to be revitalized in the
Church in Europe. It must be reaffirmed, however, that the form of the sacrament
is the personal confession of sins followed by individual absolution. This
encounter between the penitent and the priest should be encouraged in any of the
forms provided for in the rite of the sacrament. Faced with the
widespread loss of the sense of sin and the growth of a mentality marked by
relativism and subjectivism in morality, every ecclesial community needs to
provide for the serious formation of consciences.129 The Synod Fathers have insisted on the recognition of the reality of
personal sin and the necessity of personal forgiveness by God through the
ministry of the priest. Collective absolutions are not an alternative way of
administering the Sacrament of Reconciliation.130
77. I appeal to priests and I encourage them to give generously of their
time in hearing confessions and to be an example to others by their own regular
reception of the Sacrament of Penance. I urge them to keep current in the field
of moral theology, in order to approach knowledgeably the issues which have
lately arisen in personal and social morality. Furthermore, they should be
particularly concerned for the concrete living situation of the faithful, and
capable of patiently guiding them to a recognition of the requirements of
Christian moral law, so as to help them experience the sacrament as a joyous
encounter with the mercy of the Heavenly Father.131
Prayer and life
78. Together with the celebration of the Eucharist, there is also a need to
promote other forms of community prayer 132 and to help people to rediscover the bond linking the latter and
liturgical prayer. In particular, in fidelity to the tradition of the Latin
Church, different forms of Eucharistic worship outside of Mass
should be promoted: private adoration, Eucharistic exposition and processions,
which should be seen as an expression of faith in the continuing real presence
of the Lord in the Sacrament of the Altar.133 In both personal and communal celebrations of the Liturgy of the Hours,
which the Second Vatican Council recommended as also of great value for the lay
faithful,134 efforts should be made to show their relationship with the Eucharistic
mystery. Families should be encouraged to make time to pray together, and thus
to interpret the whole of marriage and family life in the light of the Gospel.
In this way, starting in the family and in hearing the word of God, a
domestic liturgy will gradually emerge, which will then mark every event in
the life of the family.135
Every form of community prayer presupposes individual prayer. Between the
individual and God there arises that true converse which finds expression in
praise, thanksgiving and petition addressed to the Father through Jesus Christ
and in the Holy Spirit. Personal prayer, which is as it were the very breath of
the Christian, should never be neglected. There is also a need to help the
faithful to rediscover the link between this personal prayer and liturgical
79. Special consideration also needs to be given to popular piety.136 Widely
diffused in different areas of Europe through confraternities, pilgrimages
and processions to numerous shrines, it enriches the unfolding of the liturgical
year and inspires traditions and customs in families and in society. All
these forms of popular piety should be carefully evaluated through a pastoral
effort of promotion and renewal aimed at helping them to accent those elements
which authentically express the wisdom of the People of God. An example
of such devotions is surely the Holy Rosary. In this Year dedicated to the
Rosary, I once more heartily recommend its recitation, for “the Rosary,
reclaimed in its full meaning, goes to the very heart of Christian life;
it offers a familiar yet fruitful spiritual and educational opportunity
for personal contemplation, the formation of the People of God, and the
With regard to popular piety, constant vigilance is needed in order to prevent
ambiguities in certain of its manifestations, to preserve them from secularizing
influences, crass commercialization or even the risk of superstition, and to
keep them within sound and authentic forms. This calls for a work of education
aimed at explaining how popular piety must always find expression in a way
consonant with the Church's liturgy and in relation to the sacraments.
80. It must not be forgotten that the “spiritual worship holy and acceptable
to God” (cf. Rom 12:1) takes place above all in daily life,
lived in charity through the free and generous gift of self, even at times
of apparent powerlessness. In this way life comes to be inspired by indestructible
hope, for it is entrusted to the certainty of God's power and the victory
of Christ alone. It becomes a life filled with the consolations of God,
with which we, in turn, are called to bring comfort to those whom we encounter
along the way (cf. 2 Cor 1:4).
The Lord's Day
81. The Lord's day is a a highly evocative and defining moment in the
celebration of the Gospel of hope.
Nowadays it is more and more difficult for Christians to be able fully to
experience Sunday as the day of encounter with the Lord. Not infrequently Sunday
is reduced to a “weekend”, a simple time of recreation. Thus there is need for a
structured pastoral programme with educational, spiritual and social components
which can help people to experience the true meaning of Sunday.
82. Consequently I renew my encouragement to “recover the deepest meaning of
the day of the Lord.138 Sunday should sanctified by sharing in the Eucharist and by rest enriched
with Christian joy and fellowship. It needs to be celebrated as the heart of all
worship, an unceasing prefigurement of unending life, which reinvigorates hope
and encourages us on our journey. There should be no fear, then, of defending
the Lord's day against every attack and making every effort to ensure that
in the organization of labour it is safeguarded, so that it can be a day
meant for man, to the benefit of all society. Indeed, were Sunday deprived of
its original meaning and it were no longer possible to make suitable time for
prayer, rest, fellowship and joy, the result could very well be that “people
stay locked within a horizon so limited that they can no longer see 'the
heavens'. Hence, though ready to celebrate, they are really incapable of doing
so”.139 And without the dimension of celebration, hope would have no home
in which to dwell.
SERVING THE GOSPEL OF HOPE
“I know your works, your love and faith and service and patient endurance” (Rev 2:19)
The way of love
83. The word which the Spirit speaks to the Churches contains a judgment
about their life. It concerns facts and forms of conduct. “I know your
works” is the introduction which, like a refrain with minor variations,
appears in the letters written to the seven Churches. If those works prove
positive, it is because they are the result of effort, constancy, endurance in
trial and tribulation, poverty, fidelity in time of persecution, charity, faith
and service. The letters can thus be read as the description of a Church which,
even more than proclaiming and celebrating the salvation which comes to her from
the Lord, concretely “lives” it.
In order to serve the Gospel of hope, the Church in Europe is also called to follow the path of love. This path takes the form of a charity which evangelizes, a broad gamut of
commitments in the service of others, and a decision for a generosity which is persevering and
knows no limits.
I. The service of charity
In communion and solidarity
84. For every person, charity received and given is the primordial
experience which gives rise to hope. “Man cannot live without hope. He
remains a being that is incomprehensible for himself, his life is senseless, if
love is not revealed to him, if he does not encounter love, if he does not
experience it and make it his own. If he does not participate intimately in it”.140
The challenge for the Church in Europe today consists, therefore, in helping
contemporary man to experience the love of God the Father and of Christ in the
Holy Spirit, through the witness of charity, which possesses an intrinsic
power of evangelization.
In the end this is the real meaning of the “Gospel”, the good news meant for
every human being: God first loved us (cf. 1 Jn 4: 10, 19) and Jesus has
loved us to the end (cf. Jn 13:1). Thanks to the gift of the Spirit,
God's love is offered to believers, enabling them to become sharers in his own
capacity to love: it becomes a powerful force in the heart of every disciple and
in all the Church (cf. 2 Cor 5:14). Precisely because it is a gift of
God, charity becomes a commandment for everyone (cf. Jn 13: 34).
To live in charity thus becomes good news addressed to every person, and
makes visible the love of God who abandons no one. In the last analysis, it
means giving those who have lost their way real reasons for continuing to hope.
85. It is the vocation of the Church, as a “credible sign – even if imperfect – of
an existential and experiential love, to lead men and women to an encounter with
the love of God and Christ, who comes in search of them”.141 The Church bears witness that she is the “sign and instrument of communion
with God and of unity among men”142 when individuals, families and communities live intensely the Gospel of
charity. In a word, our ecclesial communities are called to be true
training-grounds for communion.
By its very nature the witness of charity must extend beyond the confines of
ecclesial communities and reach out to every person, so that love for
everyone can become a stimulus to authentic solidarity in every part of
society. When the Church is at the service of love, she also facilitates the
growth of a “culture of solidarity” and thus helps to restore life to the
universal values of human coexistence.
In this context we need to rediscover the authentic meaning of Christian
Born of and continually nourished by faith, Christian volunteer work should
combine professional skills and genuine love, impelling those engaged in
it “to lift their feelings of good will towards others to the heights of
Christ's charity; to renew every day, amid hard work and weariness, their
awareness of the dignity of every person; to search out people's needs and,
where necessary, to set out on new paths where needs are greater but care
and support weaker”.143
II. Serving men and women in society
Giving new hope to the poor
86. The whole Church is called to give new hope to the poor. In the
Church, to welcome and serve the poor means to welcome and serve Christ (cf.
Mt 25:40). Preferential love for the poor is a necessary dimension of
Christian existence and service to the Gospel. To love the poor, and to testify
that they are especially loved by God, means acknowledging that persons have
value in themselves, apart from their economic, cultural, and social status, and
helping them to make the most of their potential.
87. There is a need, then, to confront the challenge of unemployment,
which in many nations of Europe represents a grave blight on society. To this
can be added the problems connected with the increase in migration. The Church
is called to remember that labour constitutes a good for which society as a
whole must feel responsible.
While restating the ethical criteria which must guide the marketplace
and the economy in scrupulous respect for the centrality of the human person,
the Church will not fail to engage in dialogue with persons involved in
political life, unions and business.144 This dialogue should aim at building a Europe seen as a community
of peoples and individuals, a community joined together in hope, not exclusively
subject to the law of the marketplace but resolutely determined to safeguard the
dignity of the human person also in social and economic relations.
88. Due importance must also be given to the pastoral care of the sick.
Since sickness is a situation which raises fundamental questions about the
meaning of life, “in a prosperous and efficient society, in a culture
characterized by idolatry of the body, dismissal of suffering and pain and by
the myth of perennial youth”,145 the care of the sick is to be considered a priority. To this end, an
appropriate pastoral presence needs to be ensured in the different places where
the suffering are found, as for example through the committed work of hospital
chaplains, members of volunteer associations and Church-associated health care
institutions, while on the other hand support should be provided for the
families of the sick. There is also a need for a suitable pastoral presence
among medical and paramedical personnel, in order to support them in their
demanding vocation in the service of the sick. In their work, health care
personnel daily render a noble service to life. They too are called to offer
patients that special spiritual support which builds on the warmth of an
authentic human contact.
89. Finally, it cannot be forgotten that at times improper use is made of the
goods of the earth. By failing in his mission of cultivating and caring for
the land with wisdom and love (cf. Gen 2:15), man has in fact devastated
woodlands and plains in many regions, polluted bodies of water, made the air
unbreathable, upset hydro-geological and atmospheric systems and caused the
desertification of vast areas.
In this case too, rendering service to the Gospel of hope means committing
ourselves in new ways to a proper use of the goods of the earth,146 encouraging that sense of concern which, in addition to safeguarding
natural habitats, defends the quality of the life of individuals and thus
prepares for future generations an environment more in harmony with the
The truth about marriage and the family
90. The Church in Europe at every level must faithfully proclaim anew the
truth about marriage and the family.147 She sees this as burning need, for she knows that this task is integral to
the mission of evangelization entrusted to her by her Bridegroom and Lord, and
imposes itself today with unusual force. Many cultural, social and political
factors are in fact conspiring to create an increasingly evident crisis of the family. In varying ways they
jeopardize the truth and dignity of the human person, and call into question, often misrepresenting it,
the notion of the family itself. The value of marital indissolubility is
increasingly denied; demands are made for the legal recognition of de facto
relationships as if they were comparable to legitimate marriages; and attempts
are made to accept a definition of the couple in which difference of sex is not
In this context the Church is called to proclaim with renewed vigour what the
Gospel teaches about marriage and the family, in order to grasp their
meaning and value in God's saving plan. In particular it is necessary to
reaffirm that these institutions are realities grounded in the will of God.
There is a need to rediscover the truth about the family as an intimate
communion of life and love148 open to the procreation of new persons, as well as its dignity as a
“domestic Church” and its share in the mission of the Church and in the life of
91. According to the Synod Fathers, recognition is due to
the many families who, in the simplicity of a daily existence lived in love,
are visible witnesses of the presence of Jesus who accompanies and sustains
them with the gift of his Spirit. In order to support their journey, it
will be necessary to enrich the theology and spirituality of marriage and
family life; to proclaim with firmness and integrity, and to demonstrate
by convincing examples, the truth and the beauty of the family founded upon
marriage and understood as a stable and fruitful union of a man and a woman;
and to promote in every ecclesial community an adequate and integrated programme
of pastoral care for the family. At the same time the Church will need,
with maternal concern, to provide assistance to those who are in difficult
situations, such as single mothers, the separated, the divorced, and abandoned
children. In all events it will be necessary to encourage, assist and support
families, both individually and in associations, who seek to play their
proper role in the Church and in society, and to work for the promotion
of genuine and adequate family policies on the part of individual States
and the European Union itself.149
92. With respect to young people and engaged couples, particular
attention must be given to providing education in love through special
programmes of preparation for the celebration of the Sacrament of Matrimony, as
a means of helping them to live chastely as they prepare for this moment. In her
educational activity the Church must also demonstrate a concern to provide
guidance and support to newly-married couples after the celebration of their
93. Finally, the Church is also called to be present with maternal affection
to those marital situations which could easily appear hopeless. In particular,
“with regard to the large number of broken families, the Church feels called not
to express a harsh, detached judgement, but rather to let the light of God's word, accompanied by the witness of his mercy,
shine deep within so many tragic human situations. This is the spirit in
which the pastoral care of families must also address the situation of the
faithful who are divorced and civilly remarried. They are not excluded from
the community; rather, they are encouraged to share in its life, while
undertaking a journey of growth in the spirit of the Gospel's demands. The
Church, while not concealing from them the truth about the objective moral
disorder of their situation and its consequences for sacramental practice,
wishes to show to them all her maternal closeness”.150
94. If serving the Gospel of hope calls for giving adequate attention and
priority to the family, it is equally the case that families themselves have
an irreplaceable responsibility for the Gospel of hope. With confidence and
affection, then, I renew my invitation to all Christian families living on this
continent of Europe: “Families, become what you are!” You are a living sign
of God's love: indeed, you have a “mission to guard, reveal, and communicate
love, and this is a living reflection of and a real sharing in God's love for
humanity and the love of Christ the Lord for the Church his Bride”.151
You are “a sanctuary of life: the place in which life – the gift of God can
be properly welcomed and protected against the many attacks to which it is
exposed, and can develop in accordance with what constitutes authentic human
You are the foundation of society, as the primary locus for the
“humanization” of individuals and society,153 a model for the establishment of social relations lived out in
love and in solidarity.
Be credible witnesses to the Gospel of hope! For you yourselves are “gaudium
At the service of the Gospel of life
95. The growing age and declining population in various European countries
cannot fail to be a cause of concern; the falling birthrate is in fact
symptomatic of a troubled relationship with our own future. It is a clear
indication of a lack of hope and a sign of the “culture of death” present in
Together with the decline in the birthrate, mention should be made of other
factors that have obscured the sense of the value of life, and led to a kind of
conspiracy against life. Sadly, among these factors must be numbered, first of
all, the spread of abortion, also through the use of
chemical-pharmaceutical preparations which make abortion possible without the
involvement of a physician and in a way detached from any form of social
responsibility. This is favoured by the fact that the legal systems of many
European countries contain legislation permitting an act which remains an
“abominable crime”156 and which always constitutes a grave moral disorder. Mention must also be
made of attacks involving “forms of intervention on human embryos which,
although carried out for purposes legitimate in themselves, inevitably involve the killing of those embryos” or the
incorrect use of prenatal diagnostic techniques, which are placed at the service
not of early detection and possible treatment but of “a eugenic intention which
accepts selective abortion”.157
We must also mention the presence of a tendency in certain parts of Europe to
consider it permissible to make a conscious decision to end one's own life or
that of another human being: the result is the spread of covert, or even openly
practised euthanasia, the legalization of which is often sought and,
tragically, at times achieved.
96. Given this state of affairs, it is necessary to serve the Gospel of life
through “a general mobilization of consciences and a united ethical
effort to activate a great campaign in support of life. All together, we
must build a new culture of life”.158 This is the great challenge which we must accept as our responsibility, in
the certainty that “the future of European civilization greatly depends on the
resolute defence and promotion of the life-giving values which are the core of
its cultural patrimony”.159 This means restoring to Europe her true dignity as a place where every
person is affirmed in his or her incomparable dignity.
I gladly make my own these words of the Synod Fathers: “The Synod of European
Bishops encourages Christian communities to become evangelizers of life.
It encourages Christian couples and families to support one another in
fidelity to their mission as cooperators with God in the generation and education
of new creatures. It values every generous effort to react to a selfishness
in the area of transmitting life encouraged by false models of security
and happiness. It asks the States of the European Union to enact far-sighted
policies aimed at fostering concrete conditions of housing, employment and
social services suitable for favouring the establishment of families and
enabling them to respond to the call to parenthood, and also to assure today's
Europe of its most precious resource: the Europeans of tomorrow”.160
Building a city worthy of man
97. A charity which bears fruit in works makes us committed to hastening the
coming of the future Kingdom. It therefore cooperates in promoting the authentic
values which are the basis of a civilization worthy of man. As the Second
Vatican Council recalled: “Christians, on pilgrimage towards the heavenly city,
should seek and savour the things which are above. This duty in no way
decreases, but rather increases, the weight of their obligation to work with all
people in building a more human world”.161 Our expectation of new heavens and a new earth, far from
withdrawing us from history, intensifies our concern for the present life, which
even now contains that newness which is the seed and the sign of the world yet
Inspired by these certainties of faith, let us strive to build a city worthy
of man. Though it is impossible to create within history a perfect social
order, we know that God blesses every sincere effort to build a better world,
and that every seed of justice and love planted in the present will bear fruit
98. In building a city worthy of man, a guiding role should be played by the
Church's social teaching. Through this teaching the Church challenges
the continent of Europe about the moral quality of its civilization. This social
doctrine arises from the encounter of the biblical message and human reason on
the one hand, and on the other with the problems and situations involving
individual and social life. By the body of principles which it sets forth, the
Church's social doctrine helps lay solid foundations for a humane coexistence in
justice, peace, freedom and solidarity. Because it is aimed at defending and
promoting the dignity of the human person, which is the basis not only of
economic and political life, but also of social justice and peace, this doctrine
proves capable of upholding the supporting structures of Europe's future.162 It contains points of reference which make it possible to defend the moral
structure of freedom, so as to protect European culture and society both from
the totalitarian utopia of “justice without freedom” and from the utopia of
“freedom without truth” which goes hand in hand with a false concept of
“tolerance”. Both utopias portend errors and horrors for humanity, as the recent history of Europe sadly attests.163
99. Because of its intrinsic connection with the dignity of the human person,
the Church's social doctrine is also capable of being appreciated by those who
are not members of the community of believers. It is urgent, then, that this
doctrine be better known and studied, and that more and more Christians become
familiar with it. The new Europe now being built demands this, since it requires
individuals formed in these values and disposed to working for the attainment of
the common good. This will require the presence of Christian lay faithful who,
by their various responsibilities in civic life, the economy, culture, health
care, education and politics, are able by their activities to imbue these
spheres with the values of the Kingdom.164
Towards a culture of acceptance
100. The challenges presently facing our service of the Gospel of hope include
the growing phenomenon of immigration, which calls on the Church's
ability to welcome each person regardless of the people or nation to which he or
she belongs. This phenomenon is also prompting European society and its
institutions as a whole to seek a just order and forms of coexistence capable of
respecting everyone, as well as the demands of legality, within a feasible
process of integration.
If we consider, among the causes which lead many to leave their own land, the
state of extreme poverty, underdevelopment and insufficient freedom which
unfortunately still characterizes various countries, there is a need for
courageous commitment on the part of all to bring about a more just
international economic order capable of promoting the authentic development
of every people and country.
101. The phenomenon of migration challenges Europe's ability to provide for
forms of intelligent acceptance and hospitality. A “universal” vision of
the common good demands this: we need to broaden our gaze to embrace the needs
of the entire human family. The phenomenon of globalization itself calls for
openness and sharing, if it is not to be a source of exclusion and
marginalization, but rather a basis for solidarity and the sharing of all in the
production and exchange of goods.
Everyone must work for the growth of a mature culture of acceptance
which, in taking into account the equal dignity of each person and need for
solidarity with the less fortunate, calls for the recognition of the
fundamental rights of each immigrant. Public authorities have the
responsibility of controlling waves of migration with a view to the requirements
of the common good. The acceptance of immigrants must always respect the norms
of law and must therefore be combined, when necessary, with a firm
suppression of abuses.
102. There is also a need for commitment in identifying possible forms of
genuine integration on the part of immigrants who have been legitimately
received into the social and cultural fabric of the different European nations.
This demands not yielding to indifference regarding universal human values and a
concern for safeguarding the cultural patrimony proper to each nation. Peaceful
coexistence and the exchange of mutual interior riches will make it possible to
build a Europe capable of becoming a home for everyone, in which each person can
be welcomed and none will suffer discrimination, where all people are treated
responsibly and can live responsibly as members of a single great family.
103. On her part, the Church is called “to continue her activity in creating and
continually improving her services of welcome and her pastoral
attention for immigrants and refugees”,165 in order to ensure respect for their dignity and freedom and to promote
In particular, specific pastoral care needs to be given to the integration of
Catholic immigrants, with respect for their culture and their distinct
religious traditions. To this end, contacts should be encouraged between the
Churches in their native countries and those to which they have migrated, in
order to study forms of assistance which could include the presence among
immigrants of priests, consecrated men and women, and properly trained pastoral
workers from their own countries.
The service of the Gospel also requires the Church, in defending the cause of
the oppressed and excluded, to call on the political authorities of the
different States and the leaders of European institutions to grant refugee
status to those who have left their country of origin because of threats to
their life, to help them return to their countries, and to create conditions
favouring respect for the dignity of all immigrants and the defence of their
Let us commit ourselves to charity!
104. The appeal to exercise an active charity, which the Synod Fathers addressed
to all the Christians of the European continent,167 represents the happy synthesis of an authentic service of the
Gospel of hope. I now propose it anew to you, the Church of Christ in Europe.
The joys and hopes, the sorrows and anxieties of contemporary Europeans,
especially the poor and the suffering, must also be your joys and your hopes,
your sorrows and your anxieties. May nothing which is genuinely human lack an
echo in your heart. Look upon Europe and upon its future with the sympathy of
one who appreciates every positive element, yet do not close your eyes to all
that is inconsistent with the Gospel and denounce it forcefully.
105. Church in Europe, welcome every day with renewed freshness the gift of
charity which your Lord offers to you and enables you to accept.
Learn from him the content and the measure of love. Be the Church of the
Beatitudes, constantly conformed to Christ (cf. Mt 5:1-12).
Free from all forms of hindrance and dependency, be poor yourself and a friend
to the poor, welcoming every person and attentive to all forms of poverty, both
old and new.
Continuously purified by the Father's goodness, see in the attitude of Christ,
who always defended the truth yet still showed mercy towards sinners, the
supreme norm of all your actions.
In Jesus, at whose birth peace was proclaimed (cf. Lk 2:14), in him whose
death broke down the walls of enmity (cf. Eph 2:14) and brought true
peace (cf. Jn 14:27), be a builder of peace. Encourage your sons and
daughters to allow their hearts to be purified of all hostility, selfishness and
partisanship, and to favour at all times mutual dialogue and respect.
In Jesus, who is the justice of God, never grow weary of denouncing injustice in
all its forms. Living in the world with the values of the Kingdom to come, you
will be a Church of charity and you will make your indispensable contribution to
the building in Europe of a civilization ever more worthy of man.
THE GOSPEL OF HOPE FOR A NEW EUROPE
“And I saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven” (Rev 21:2)
The newness of God in history
106. The Gospel of hope resounding throughout the Book of Revelation opens our
hearts to the contemplation of the newness brought about by God: “I saw a
new heaven and a new earth; for the first heaven and the first earth had passed
away” (Rev 21:1). God himself says as much, in the words explaining the
vision which has just taken place: “Behold, I make all things new” (Rev
The newness of God which can only be fully understood against the backdrop of the
old things, made up of tears, mourning, lamentation, travail and death (cf.
Rev 21:4) – consists in leaving behind the state of sin and its consequences
in which humanity finds itself; it is the new heavens and the new earth, the new
Jerusalem, in contrast to the old heaven and earth, an obsolete order of things
and an old Jerusalem, tormented by its rivalries.
The image of the new Jerusalem coming down “out of heaven from God, prepared as
a bride adorned for her husband” (Rev 21:2) is a direct reference to the
mystery of the Church and is not irrelevant for building the city of man. It is
an image which speaks of an eschatological reality which transcends human
possibilities and is a gift of God which will appear in the last days. Yet it is
not a utopia: it is a reality already in our midst. This can be seen by
the present tense of the verbs which God uses: “Behold, I make all things
new” (Rev 21:5), and, as a further clarification: “It is done!” (Rev
21:6). God is already at work renewing the world; the newness of God is already
found in Jesus' Pasch. It is this which brings the Church to birth, inspires her
life, and renews and transforms her history.
107. This newness begins to take shape first of all in the Christian
community, which is even now “the dwelling of God with men” (Rev
21:3), in whose midst God is already at work, renewing the life of all who yield
to the Spirit's breath. The Church is for the world a sign and instrument of the
Kingdom which comes about first in human hearts. A reflection of this newness
can also be seen in every form of human coexistence inspired by the Gospel.
It is a newness that speaks to society at every moment of history and in every
place on earth, and in particular to European society, which for so many
centuries has heard the Gospel of the Kingdom inaugurated by Jesus.
I. Europe's spiritual vocation
Europe as a promoter of universal values
108. The history of the European continent has been distinctively marked by the
life-giving influence of the Gospel. “If we turn our gaze to the past centuries,
we can only give thanks to the Lord that on our continent Christianity has
been a primary factor of unity among peoples and cultures and of the
integral promotion of man and his rights”.168
There can be no doubt that the Christian faith belongs, in a radical and
decisive way, to the foundations of European culture. Christianity in fact has
shaped Europe, impressing upon it certain basic values. Modern Europe itself,
which has given the democratic ideal and human rights to the world, draws its
values from its Christian heritage. More than a geographical area, Europe can be
described as “a primarily cultural and historical concept, which denotes
a reality born as a continent thanks also to the unifying force of Christianity,
which has been capable of integrating peoples and cultures among themselves, and
which is intimately linked to the whole of European culture”.169
Today's Europe however, at the very moment it is in the process of strengthening
and enlarging its economic and political union, seems to suffer from a profound
crisis of values. While possessed of increased resources, it gives the
impression of lacking the energy needed to sustain a common project and to give its citizens new reasons for hope.
The new face of Europe
109. In the process of transformation which it is now undergoing, Europe is called above all to rediscover its true identity. Even though it has developed into a highly diversified reality, it needs to
build a new model of unity in diversity, as a community of reconciled nations
open to the other continents and engaged in the present process of
To give new impetus to its own history, Europe must “recognize and reclaim
with creative fidelity those fundamental values, acquired through a decisive
contribution of Christianity, which can be summarized in the affirmation of the
transcendent dignity of the human person, the value of reason, freedom,
democracy, the constitutional state and the distinction between political life
110. The European Union continues to expand. All peoples who share its same
fundamental heritage have a vocation to take part in it, on a short-term or a
long-term basis. It is to be hoped that this expansion will come about in a way
that respects all people, valuing their historical and cultural distinctions,
their national identities and the great contributions which can come from new
members. It should also take place in a way that puts into practice in an ever
more fully developed manner the principles of subsidiarity and solidarity.171 In the process of the continent's integration, it is of capital importance
to remember that the union will lack substance if it is reduced to its merely
geographic and economic dimensions; rather, it must consist above all in an
agreement about the values which must find expression in its law and in its
Promoting solidarity and peace in the world
111. Saying “Europe” must be equivalent to saying “openness”. Despite
experiences and signs to the contrary, which it has not lacked, European history
itself demands this: “Europe is really not a closed or isolated territory; it
has been built by expanding overseas and meeting other peoples, other cultures,
other civilizations”.172 Therefore it needs to be an open and welcoming Continent,
continuing to develop in the current process of globalization forms of
cooperation which are not merely economic but social and cultural as well.
There is one need to which Europe must respond positively if it is to have a
truly new face: “Europe cannot close in on itself. It cannot and must not lose
interest in the rest of the world. On the contrary, it must remain fully aware
of the fact that other countries, other continents, await its bold initiatives,
in order to offer to poorer peoples the means for their growth and social
organization, and to build a more just and fraternal world”.173 To carry out this mission adequately will demand “rethinking
international cooperation in terms of a new culture of solidarity. When seen
as a sowing of peace, cooperation cannot be reduced to aid or assistance,
especially if given with an eye to the benefits to be received in return for the
resources made available. Rather, it must express a concrete and tangible
commitment to solidarity which makes the poor the agents of their own
development and enables the greatest number of people, in their specific
economic and political circumstances, to exercise the creativity which is
characteristic of the human person and on which the wealth of nations too is
112. Europe must moreover become an active partner in promoting and
implementing a globalization “in” solidarity. This must be accompanied, as a
pre-condition, by a kind of globalization “of” solidarity and of the
related values of equity, justice and freedom, based on the firm conviction that
the marketplace needs to be “appropriately controlled by the forces of society
and by the state, so as to guarantee that the basic needs of the whole of
society are satisfied”.175
The Europe handed down to us by history has witnessed the rise, especially in
the last century, of totalitarian ideologies and extreme forms of nationalism
which darkened the hopes of individuals and the peoples on the Continent and
sparked conflicts both within and between nations, leading up to the immense
tragedy of the two World Wars.176 More recent ethnic conflicts, which have again led to bloodshed on
the continent of Europe, have once more demonstrated to everyone how fragile
peace is, how it requires an active commitment on the part of all, and how it
can be ensured only by opening up new prospects of exchange, forgiveness and
reconciliation between individuals, peoples and nations.
In this state of affairs, Europe, with all its inhabitants, needs to work
tirelessly to build peace within its borders and throughout the world. In
this regard, it must be recalled that “on the one hand, national differences
ought to be maintained and encouraged as the foundation of European
solidarity, while on the other, national identity itself can only be achieved in
openness towards other peoples and through solidarity with them”.177
II. The Building Up of Europe
The role of European Institutions
113. In the work of creating a new face for the continent, the role of
international institutions is
in many ways decisive. Associated with and operating principally on European
territory, they have left their a mark on the course of historical events
without being engaged in operations of a military character. In this regard
I wish to mention first of all the Organization for Security and Cooperation
in Europe, which works to maintain peace and stability, also through the
protection and promotion of human rights and fundamental freedoms, and through
economic and environmental cooperation.
There is also the Council of Europe, made up of those states which were
signatories to the 1950 European Convention for the safeguarding of fundamental
human rights and the 1961 Social Charter. Connected to them is the European
Court of Human Rights. These two institutions seek, by means of political,
social, juridic and cultural cooperation, as well as by the promotion of human
rights and democracy, to build a Europe of freedom and solidarity. Finally,
the European Union, with its Parliament, its Council of Ministers and its
Commission, proposes a model of integration which is to be perfected by the
eventual adoption of a common fundamental charter. This body has the aim of
achieving greater political, economic and monetary unity between the member
states, both present and future. In their diversity and on the basis of the
specific identity of each, the European Institutions promote the unity of the
continent, and, more profoundly, are at the service of mankind.178
114. Together with the Synod Fathers,179 I ask these same European institutions and the individual states of Europe
to recognize that a proper ordering of society must be rooted in authentic
ethical and civil values shared as widely as possible by its citizens; at
the same time I would note that these values are the patrimony, in the first
place, of the various social bodies. It is important that the institutions and
the individual states recognize that these social bodies also include Churches
and Ecclesial Communities and other religious organizations. Even more so, in
those cases where these already existed before the foundation of European
nations, they cannot be reduced to merely private entities but act with a
specific institutional import which merits being given serious consideration. In
carrying out their functions the various national and European institutions
should act in the awareness that their juridical systems will be fully
respectful of democracy, if they provide for forms of “healthy cooperation”
180 with Churches and religious organizations.
In the light of what I have just emphasized, I wish once more to appeal to those
drawing up the future European constitutional treaty, so that it will include a
reference to the religious and in particular the Christian heritage of Europe.
While fully respecting the secular nature of the institutions, I consider it
desirable especially that three complementary elements should be recognized: the
right of Churches and religious communities to organize themselves freely in
conformity with their statutes and proper convictions; respect for the specific
identity of the different religious confessions and provision for a structured
dialogue between the European Union and those confessions; and respect for the
juridical status already enjoyed by Churches and religious institutions by
virtue of the legislation of the member states of the Union.181
115. The European institutions have as their declared purpose the defence of the
rights of the human person. In carrying out this task they contribute to the
building of the Europe of values and of law. The Synod Fathers called upon the
leaders of Europe in the following words: “Raise your voices in the face of the
violation of human rights of individuals, minorities and peoples,
beginning with the right to religious freedom; pay utmost attention to
everything that concerns human life from the moment of its conception to
natural death and to the family based on marriage: these are the
foundations on which our common European home rests; ... respond, with justice
and equity and with a great sense of solidarity, to the growing phenomenon of
migration, and see in it a new resource for the future of Europe; make every
effort to guarantee young people a truly humane future with work, culture,
and education in moral and spiritual values”.182
The Church for the new Europe
116. Europe needs a religious dimension. If it is to be “new”, by analogy
with what is said about the “new city” of the Book of Revelation (cf. 21:2), it
must open itself to the workings of God. The hope of building a more just world,
a world more worthy of man, cannot prescind from a realization that human effort
will be of no avail unless it is accompanied by divine assistance: for “unless
the Lord builds the house, those who build it labour in vain” (Ps 127:1).
For Europe to be built on solid foundations, there is a need to call upon authentic values grounded in
the universal moral law written on the heart of every man and woman. “Not only
can Christians join with all people of goodwill in working to build this great
project, but they are also called to be in some way its heart, revealing the
true meaning of the organization of the earthly city”.183
One and universal, yet present in the multiplicity of the Particular Churches,
the Catholic Church can offer a unique contribution to the building up of a
Europe open to the world. The Catholic Church in fact provides a model of
essential unity in a diversity of cultural expressions, a consciousness of
membership in a universal community which is rooted in but not confined to local
communities, and a sense of what unites beyond all that divides.184
117. In her relations with public authorities the Church is not calling for a
return to the confessional state. She likewise deplores every type of
ideological secularism or hostile separation between civil institutions and
For her part, in keeping with a healthy cooperation between the ecclesial
community and political society, the Catholic Church is convinced that she can
make a unique contribution to the prospect of unification by offering the
European institutions, in continuity with her tradition and in fidelity to the
principles of her social teaching, the engagement of believing communities
committed to bringing about the humanization of society on the basis of the
Gospel, lived under the sign of hope. From this standpoint, the presence of
Christians, properly trained and competent, is needed in the various
European agencies and institutions, in order to contribute – with respect for the
correct dynamics of democracy and through an exchange of proposals – to the
shaping of a European social order which is increasingly respectful of every man
and woman, and thus in accordance with the common good.
118. The Europe which must be built up as a “union” also impels Christians
towards unity so that they can be true witnesses of hope. In this context,
the exchange of gifts, which in this last decade has had significant
expressions, should be continued and developed. When it takes place between
communities with different histories and traditions, it leads to more durable
bonds between the Churches in different countries and their reciprocal
enrichment through meetings, exchanges of ideas and mutual assistance. In
particular the contribution of the cultural and spiritual tradition offered by
the Eastern Catholic Churches needs to be better appreciated.185
An important role in the growth of this unity can be played by continental
organizations of ecclesial communion, which need to be further encouraged.186
Among these a significant place must be given to the Council of
European Episcopal Conferences, which is called on the continental level “to
provide for the promotion of an ever more intense communion among Dioceses and
the national Episcopal Conferences, for the growth in ecumenical cooperation among
Christians and the overcoming of obstacles which threaten the future of peace
and the progress of peoples, for the strengthening of affective and effective
collegiality and of hierarchical communion”.187 Together with the Council, acknowledgment must also be made of the service
provided by the Commission of the Episcopates of the European Community,
which, in following the process of consolidation and enlargement of the European
Union, favours the sharing of information and coordinates the pastoral
initiatives of the European Churches involved.
119. The strengthening of union in Europe motivates Christians to cooperate in
the process of integration and reconciliation through a theological, spiritual,
ethical and social dialogue.188 Indeed, “in the Europe which is proceeding towards political unity, can we
accept that the Church of Christ is herself a factor of division and of discord?
Would this not be one of the greatest scandals of our time?”.189
From the Gospel, a new enthusiasm for Europe
120. Europe needs to make a qualitative leap in becoming conscious of its
spiritual heritage. The impetus for this can only come from hearing anew the
Gospel of Jesus Christ. It is the responsibility of all Christians to commit
themselves to satisfying this hunger and thirst for life.
Consequently “the Church feels it her duty to repeat vigourously the message of
hope entrusted to her by God” and says again to Europe: “ 'The Lord your God
is in your midst, a mighty Saviour!' (Zeph 3:17). Her invitation to
hope is not based on a utopian ideology; on the contrary, it is the timeless
message of salvation proclaimed by Christ (cf. Mk 1:15). With the
authority she has received from her Lord, the Church repeats to today's Europe:
Europe of the third millennium, “let not your hands grow weak! (Zeph
3:16); do not give in to discouragement, do not resign yourself to ways of
thinking and living that have no future because they are not based on the solid
certainty of God's Word!”.190
Taking up anew this invitation to hope, I repeat to you again today: Europe, as you stand at the beginning of the third millennium, “Open the doors to
Christ! Be yourself. Rediscover your origins. Relive your roots”.191Down the centuries you have received the treasure of Christian faith. It has
grounded your life as a society on principles drawn from the Gospel, and traces
of this are evident in the art, literature, thought and culture of your nations.
But this heritage does not belong just to the past; it is a project in the
making, to be passed on to future generations, for it has indelibly marked the
life of the individuals and peoples who together have forged the continent of
121. Do not be afraid! The Gospel is not against you, but for you. This
is confirmed by the fact that Christian inspiration is capable of transforming political, cultural and
economic groupings into a form of coexistence in which all Europeans will feel
at home and will form a family of nations from which other areas of the world
can draw fruitful inspiration.
Be confident! In the Gospel, which is Jesus, you will find the sure and lasting
hope to which you aspire. This hope is grounded in the victory of Christ over sin and death. He wishes
this victory to be your own, for your salvation and your joy.
Be certain! The Gospel of hope does not disappoint! Throughout the vicissitudes of your history, yesterday and today, it is a
the light which illumines and directs your way; it is the strength which
sustains you in trials; it is the prophecy of a new world; it is the sign of a
new beginning; it is the invitation to everyone, believers and non- believers
alike, to blaze new trails leading to a “Europe of the spirit”, in order to make
the continent a true “common home” filled with the joy of life.
Entrustment to Mary
“A great portent appeared in heaven, a woman clothed with the sun” (Rev 12:1)
The Woman, the Dragon and the Child
122. The Church's journey through history is accompanied by “signs” which are
visible to all, yet need to be interpreted. Among such signs the Book of
Revelation presents the “great portent” which appeared in the sky, which speaks
of a conflict between the woman and the dragon.
The woman, clothed with the sun, in travail and ready to give birth (cf. Rev
12:1-2), can be seen as the Israel of the Prophets which gives birth to the
Messiah “who is to rule all the nations with a rod of iron” (Rev 12:5;
cf. Ps 2:9). But she is also the Church, the People of the New Covenant,
subjected to persecution and yet protected by God. The dragon is “the
ancient serpent, who is called the Devil and Satan, the deceiver of the whole
world” (Rev 12:9). The conflict is an uneven one: the dragon seems
to prevail, so great is his arrogance before the defenceless and suffering woman. Yet in reality the triumph belongs to the son
born of the woman. In this conflict one thing is certain: the great dragon
has already been defeated; “he was cast down to the earth, and his angels were
cast down with him” (Rev 12:9). He was defeated by Christ, God made man,
through his death and resurrection, and by the martyrs “through the blood of the
Lamb and by the word of their testimony” (Rev 12:11). And even when the dragon continues his opposition, there is no
reason for fear, since his defeat has already taken place.
123. This is the certainty which heartens the Church on her pilgrim way; in the
story of the woman and the dragon she reads her own history ever anew. The woman
who gives birth to her son also brings to mind the Virgin Mary,
especially at that moment when, transfixed by suffering at the foot of the
Cross, she begets her Son anew as the victor over the prince of this world. She
is then entrusted to John who in turn is entrusted to her (cf. Jn
19:26-27), and thus she becomes the Mother of the Church. Thanks to the bond
uniting Mary to the Church and the Church to Mary, the mystery of the woman
becomes clearer: “Mary, present in the Church as the Mother of the Redeemer,
takes part, as a mother, in that 'monumental struggle against the powers of
darkness,' which continues throughout human history. And by her ecclesial
identification as the 'woman clothed with the sun' (Rev 12:1), it can be
said that 'in the Most Holy Virgin the Church has already reached the perfection whereby she exists without spot or
124. The whole Church, then, looks to Mary. Thanks to the countless
Marian shrines dotting the nations of the continent, devotion to Mary is very
strong and widespread among the peoples of Europe.
Church in Europe! Continue to contemplate Mary, in the knowledge that she is “maternally present and sharing in the many
complicated problems which today beset the lives of individuals, families, and
nations” and is “helping the Christian people in the constant struggle between
good and evil, to ensure that it 'does not fall', or, if it has fallen, that it
'rises again' ”.193
Prayer to Mary, Mother of Hope
125. In this contemplation, inspired by genuine love, Mary appears to us as a
figure of the Church which, nourished by hope, acknowledges the saving and
merciful action of God, in whose light she reads her own journey and all of
history. Today too Mary helps us to interpret all that happens to us in the
light of Jesus her Son. As a new creation moulded by the Holy Spirit, Mary
causes the virtue of hope to grow within us.
To her, Mother of hope and consolation, we confidently lift up our prayer: to
her we entrust the future of the Church in Europe and the future of all the
women and men of this continent:
Mary, Mother of hope,
accompany us on our journey!
Teach us to proclaim the living God;
help us to bear witness to Jesus,
the one Saviour;
make us kindly towards our neighbours,
welcoming to the needy,
concerned for justice,
impassioned builders of a more just world;
intercede for us
as we carry out our work in history,
certain that the Father's plan will be fulfilled.
Dawn of a new world,
show yourself the Mother of hope
and watch over us!
Watch over the Church in Europe:
may she be transparently open to the Gospel;
may she be an authentic place
may she carry out fully her mission
of proclaiming, celebrating and serving
the Gospel of hope
for the peace and joy of all.
Queen of Peace,
Protect the men and women of the third millennium!
Watch over all Christians:
may they advance confidently
on the path of unity,
as a leaven of harmony for the continent.
Watch over young people:
the hope of the future,
may they respond with generosity
to the call of Jesus.
Watch over the leaders of nations:
may they be committed
to building a common house
which respects the dignity and rights
of every person.
Mary, give us Jesus!
Grant that we may follow him and love him!
He is the hope of the Church,
of Europe and of all humanity!
He lives with us, in our midst, in his Church!
With you we say:
“Come, Lord Jesus” (Rev 22:20).
May the hope of glory
which he has poured into our hearts
bear fruits of justice and peace!
Given in Rome, at Saint Peter's, on 28 June, the Vigil of the Solemnity of the
Holy Apostles Peter and Paul, in the year 2003, the twenty-fifth of my
1 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message,
1: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
2 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum
Laboris, 90-91: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 - Suppl., 17-18.
3 John Paul II, Bull Incarnationis Mysterium (29 November 1998), 3-4: AAS
91 (1999), 132, 133.
4 Cf. John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Tertio Millennio Adveniente (10
November 1994), 38: AAS 87 (1995), 30.
5 Cf. Angelus Address (23 June 1996), 2: Insegnamenti XIX/1 (1996),
6 Synod of Bishops – First Special Assembly for Europe, Final Declaration
(13 December 1991), 2: Ench. Vat. 13, No. 619.
7 Ibid., 3, loc.cit., 621.
8 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum
Laboris, 3: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 - Suppl., 3.
9 Cf. John Paul II, Homily for the Concluding Mass of the Second Special
Assembly of the Synod for Europe (23 October 1999), 1: AAS 92 (2000), 177.
10 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message,
2: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
11 Cf. John Paul II, Homily for the Concluding Mass of the Second Special
Assembly of the Synod for Europe (23 October 1999), 4: AAS 92 (2000), 179.
13 Cf. Propositio 1.
14 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris,
2: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 - Suppl., 2-3.
15 Cf. ibid., 12-13, 16-19, loc. cit., 4-6; Idem, Relatio ante disceptationem,
I: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 6-7; Idem, Relatio post
disceptationem, II, A: L'Osservatore Romano, 11-12 October
16 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, I, 1.2: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999,
17 Cf. Propositio 5a.
18 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message, 1:
L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
19 Propositio 5a. Pontifical Council for Culture and Pontifical Council for
Interreligious Dialogue, Jesus Christ The Bearer of the Water of Life. A
Christian Reflection on the New Age, Vatican City, 2003.
20 Cf. Propositio 5a.
21 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message,
6: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
22 John Paul II, Angelus Address (25 August 1996), 2; Insegnamenti
XIX/2 (1996), 237; cf. Propositio 9.
23 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris,
88: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 - Suppl., 17.
24 John Paul II, Homily during the Concluding Mass of the Second Special
Assembly of the Synod for Europe (23 October 1999), 4: AAS 92 (2000), 179.
25 Cf. John Paul II, Post Synodal Apostolic Exhortation Christifideles Laici
(30 December 1988), 26: AAS 81 (1989), 439.
26 Cf. Propositio 21.
28 Propositio 9.
30 Cf. Propositio 4, 1.
31 John Paul II, Homily during the Concluding Mass of the Second Special
Assembly of the Synod for Europe (23 October 1999), 2: AAS 92 (2000), 178.
32 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message, 2:
L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
33 Cf. Propositio 4, 2.
34 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Centesimus Annus (1 May 1991), 47: AAS 83
35 Cf. Propositio 4, 1.
36 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum
Laboris, 30: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 - Suppl., 8.
37 John Paul II, Homily during the Concluding Mass of the Second Special
Assembly of the Synod for Europe (23 October 1999), 3: AAS 92 (2000), 178; Congregation for the Doctrine
of the Faith, Declaration Dominus Iesus (6 August 2000), 13: AAS 92
38 Cf. Propositio 5.
39 Cf. John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Dominum et Vivificantem (18 May
1986), 7: AAS 78 (1986), 816; Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith,
Declaration Dominus Iesus (6 August 2000), 16: AAS 92 (2000), 756-757.
40 Paul VI, Encyclical Letter Mysterium Fidei (3 September 1965): AAS 57
(1965), 762-763. Cf. Sacred Congregation of Rites, Instruction Eucharisticum
Mysterium (25 May 1967), 9: AAS 59 (1967), 547; Catechism of the Catholic
Church, No. 1374.
41 Ecumenical Council of Trent, Decretum De ss. Eucharistia, can. 1: DS
1651; cf. cap. 3: DS 1641.
42 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Ecclesia de Eucharistia
(17 April 2003), 15: L'Osservatore Romano, 18 April 2003, 2.
43 Cf. Saint Augustine, In Ioannis Evangelium, Tractatus VI, cap. I, 7: PL
35, 1428; Saint John Chrysostom, In Proditionem Iudae, hom. I, 6: PG 49,
44 Cf. Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy
Sacrosanctum Concilium, 7; Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Lumen
Gentium, 50; Paul VI, Encyclical Letter Mysterium Fidei (3 September
1965): AAS 57 (1965), 762-763; Sacred Congregation of Rites, Instruction
Eucharisticum Mysterium (25 May 1967), 9: AAS 59 (1967), 547; Catechism
of the Catholic Church, Nos. 1373-1374.
45 John Paul II, Motu Proprio Spes Ædificandi (1 October
1999), 1: AAS 92 (2000), 220.
46 Cf. John Paul II, Address to the Polish Parliament, Warsaw (11 June
1999), 6: Insegnamenti, XXII/1 (1999), 1276.
47 Cf. John Paul II, Address during the Departure Ceremony at Krakow Airport
(10 June 1997), 4: Insegnamenti XX/1 (1997), 1496-1497.
48 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message, No.
4: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
49 Cf. Propositio 15, 1; Catechism of the Catholic Church, No. 773;
John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Mulieris Dignitatem (15 August 1988), 27:
AAS 80 (1988), 1718.
50 Cf. Propositio 15, 1.
51 Propositio 21.
52 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message, No.
4: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
53 Propositio 9.
56 Cf. Propositio 22.
57 John Paul II, Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation Pastores Dabo Vobis (25
March 1992), 15: AAS 84 (1992), 679-680.
58 Cf. ibid., 29, loc. cit., 703-705; Propositio 18.
59 Cf. Code of Canons of the Oriental Churches, can. 373.
60 Cf. Code of Canon Law, can. 277,1.
61 Cf. Paul VI, Encyclical Letter Sacerdotalis Coelibatus (24 June 1967),
40: AAS 59 (1967), 673.
62 Cf. Propositio 18.
63 Cf. ibid.
64 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message,
No. 4: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
65 Cf. Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church
Lumen Gentium, 29.
66 Cf. Propositio 19.
67 Cf. ibid.
68 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, III: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 9.
69 Propositio 17.
70 Cf. ibid.
71 John Paul II, Address to the Participants in the Congress on the Theme “New
Vocations for a New Europe” (9 May 1997), 1-3: Insegnamenti XX/1
72 John Paul II, Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation Christifideles Laici (30
December 1988), 7: AAS 81 (1989), 404.
73 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris,
No. 82: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999, 16.
74 Cf. Propositio 29.
75 Cf. Propositio 30.
76 Cf. ibid.
77 Paul VI, Apostolic Exhortation Evangelii Nuntiandi (8 December 1975), 14:
AAS 68 (1976), 13.
78 Cf. Propositio 3b.
79 Cf. John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Redemptoris Missio (7 December 1990),
37: AAS 83 (1991), 282-286.
80 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, I, 2: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 7.
81 Cf. Propositio 3a.
82 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, III,1: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 8.
83 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum
Laboris, No. 53: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999 – Suppl., 12.
84 Cf. Propositio 4,1.
85 Cf. Propositio 26,1.
86 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, III,1: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 9.
87 Paul VI, Apostolic Exhortation Evangelii Nuntiandi (8
December 1975), 41: AAS 68 (1976), 31.
88 Propositio 8,1.
89 Cf. Propositio 8,2.
90 Cf. Propositiones 8, 1a-b; 6.
91 Cf. John Paul II, Apostolic Exhortation Catechesi Tradendae
(16 October 1979), 21: AAS 71 (1979), 1294-1295.
92 Cf. Propositio 24.
93 Cf. Propositio 8,1c.
94 Cf. Propositio 24.
95 Cf. Propositio 22.
96 Cf. John Paul II, Address to the Presidents of the European Episcopal
Conferences (16 April 1993), 1: AAS 86 (1994), 227.
97 John Paul II, Address during the Ecumenical Liturgy of the Word in Paderborn
Cathedral (22 June 1996), 5: Insegnamenti XIX/1 (1996), 1571.
98 Paul VI, Letter of 13 January 1970: Tomos Agapis, Rome-Istanbul, 1971,
610-611; cf. John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Ut Unum Sint (25 May 1995),
99: AAS 87 (1995), 980.
99 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Redemptoris Missio (7 December 1990), 55:
AAS 83 (1991), 302.
100 Ibid., 36; loc. cit., 281.
101 Cf. Synod of Bishops – First Special Assembly for Europe,, Final Declaration
(13 December 1991), 8: Ench. Vat., 13, Nos. 653-655; Second Special
Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris, 62: L'Osservatore Romano,
6 August 1999 – Suppl., 13; Propositio 10.
102 Propositio 10; cf. Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, We Remember: A
Reflection on the Shoah, 16 March 1998, Ench. Vat., 1, Nos. 520-550.
103 Synod of Bishops – First Special Assembly for Europe, Final Declaration
(13 December 1991), 9; Ench. Vat., 13, No. 656.
104 Cf. Propositio 11.
105 Cf. ibid.
106 John Paul II, Address to the Diplomatic Corps (12 January 1985), 3: AAS
77 (1985), 650.
107 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Declaration on Religious Freedom
Dignitatis Humanae, 2.
108 Cf. Propositio 23.
109 Cf. Propositiones 25 and 26,2.
110 Cf. Propositio 26,3.
111 Cf. Propositio 27.
112 John Paul II, Letter to Artists (14 April 1999), 12: AAS 91 (1999), 1168.
113 Cf. Propositio 7b-c.
114 Cf. John Paul II, Address during the Prayer Vigil at Tor Vergata on the
occasion of the XV World Youth Day (19 August 2000), 6: Insegnamenti
XXIII/2 (2000), 212.
115 Cf. Pontifical Council for Social Communications, Ethics in Social
Communications, Vatican City, 4 June 2000.
116 Cf. Propositio 12.
117 Cf. Propositio 12.
118 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation
Dei Verbum, 25.
119 Cf. Propositio 14.
120 Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy Sacrosanctum Concilium, 8.
121 Cf. Propositio 14; Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe,
Relatio ante disceptationem, III, 2; L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October
122 Cf. Propositio 15,2a.
123 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Decree on the Ministry and Life of Priests
Presbyterorum Ordinis, 5.
124 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Lumen
125 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Ecclesia De Eucharistia
(17 April 2003), 20: L'Osservatore Romano, 18 April 2003, 3.
126 John Paul II, Address at the General Audience (25 October 2000), 2:
Insegnamenti XXIII/2 (2000), 697.
127 Propositio 16.
128 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Relatio ante
disceptationem, III, 2: L'Osservatore Romano, 3 October 1999, 9.
129 Cf. Propositio 16.
130 Cf. John Paul II, Motu Proprio Misericordia Dei (7 April
2002), 4: AAS 94 (2002), 456-457.
131 Cf. Propositio 16; John Paul II II, Letter to Priests for Holy
Thursday 2002 (17 March 2002), 4: AAS 94 (2002), 435- 436.
132 Cf. Propositio 14c.
133 Cf. ibid.
134 Cf. Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy Sacrosanctum Concilium, 100.
135 Cf. Propositiones 14c and 20.
136 Cf. Propositio 20.
137 John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Rosarium Virginis Mariae (16 October
2002), 3: AAS 95 (2003), 7.
138 Cf. Propositio 14.
139 John Paul II, Apostolic Letter Dies Domini (31 May 1998), 4: AAS 90
140 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Redemptor Hominis (4 March 1979),
10: AAS 71 (1979), 274.
141 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris,
72: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999, Suppl., 15.
142 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Lumen
143 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Evangelium Vitae (25 March 1995), 90: AAS
87 (1995), 503.
144 Cf. Propositio 33.
145 Propositio 35.
146 Cf. Propositio 36.
147 Cf. Propositio 31.
148 Cf. Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Pastoral Constitution on the Church in
the Modern World Gaudium et Spes, 48.
149 Cf. Propositio 31.
150 John Paul II, Address to the Third World Meeting with Families on the Occasion of their Jubilee, (14 October 2000), 6: Insegnamenti XXIII/2 (2000), 603.
151 John Paul II, Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris Consortio (22 November
1981), 17: AAS 74 (1982), 99-100.
152 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Centesimus Annus (1 May 1991), 39: AAS 83
153 Cf. John Paul II, Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation Christifideles Laici
(30 December 1988), 40: AAS 81 (1989), 469.
154 Cf. John Paul II, Address to the First World Meeting with Families (8 October 1994), 7: AAS 87 (1995), 587.
155 Cf. Propositio 32.
156 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the
Modern World Gaudium et Spes, 51.
157 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Evangelium Vitae (25 March 1995), 63: AAS
87 (1995), 473.
158 Ibid., 95: loc. cit., 509.
159 John Paul II, Address to the new Ambassador of Norway to the Holy See (25 March 1995): Insegnamenti XVIII/1 (1995), 857.
160 Propositio 32.
161 Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World Gaudium et Spes,
162 Cf. Propositio 28; Synod of Bishops – First Special Assembly for Europe,,
Final Message (13 December 1991), 10: Ench. Vat. 13, Nos. 659-669.
163 Cf. Propositio 23.
164 Cf. Propositio 28.
165 Propositio 34.
166 Cf. Congregation for Bishops, Instruction Nemo Est (22 August 1969), 16:
AAS 61 (1969), 621-622; CIC, canons 294 and 518; CCEO, canon 280 § 1.
167 Cf. Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message,
5: L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 6.
168 John Paul II, Homily at the Conclusion of the Second Special Assembly for Europe of the Synod of Bishops (23 October 1999), 5: AAS 92 (2000), 179.
169 Propositio 39.
171 Cf. ibid.; Propositio 28.
172 John Paul II, Letter to Cardinal Miloslav Vlk, President of the Council of
European Episcopal Conferences (16 October 2000), 7: Insegnamenti,
XXIII/2 (2000), 628.
174 John Paul II, Message for the 2000 Day of Peace (8 December 1999), 17:
AAS 92 (2000), 367-368.
175 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Centesimus Annus (1 May 1991), 35: AAS 83
176 Cf. Propositio 39.
177 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Instrumentum Laboris,
85: L'Osservatore Romano, 6 August 1999, Suppl., 17; cf. Propositio
178 Cf. John Paul II, Address to the Office of the Presidency of the European
Parliament (5 April 1979): Insegnamenti, II/1 (1979), 796-799.
179 Cf. Propositio, 37.
180 Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the
Modern World Gaudium et Spes, 76.
181 Cf. John Paul II, Address to the Diplomatic Corps (13 January 2003), 5:
L'Osservatore Romano, 13-14 January 2003, 6.
182 Synod of Bishops – Second Special Assembly for Europe, Final Message, 6:
L'Osservatore Romano, 23 October 1999, 5.
183 John Paul II, Letter to Cardinal Miloslav Vlk, President of the Council of
European Episcopal Conferences (16 October 2000), 4: Insegnamenti
XXIII/2 (2000), 626.
184 Cf. Synod of Bishops – First Special Assembly for Europe, Final Declaration,
10: Ench. Vat. 13, No. 669.
185 Cf. Propositio 22.
186 Cf. ibid.
187 John Paul II, Address to
the Presidents of the Episcopal Conferences of Europe (16 April 1993), 5:
AAS 86 (1994), 229.
188 Cf. Propositio 39d.
189 John Paul II, Homily during the Ecumenical Celebration on the occasion of the
Special Assembly for Europe of the Synod of Bishops (7 December 1991), 6:
Insegnamenti XIV/2 (1991), 1330.
190 John Paul II, Homily for the Opening of the Second Special Assembly of the
Synod for Europe (1 October 1999), 3: AAS 92 (2000), 174-175.
191 Address to European Authorities and to the Presidents of the Episcopal
Conferences of Europe (9 November 1982), 4: AAS 75 (1983), 330.
192 John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Redemptoris Mater (25 March 1987), 47:
AAS 79 (1987), 426.
193 Ibid., 52: loc. cit., 432; cf. Propositio 40.