Pope John Paul II calls for improved prison conditions and a gesture
of clemency towards prisoners
1. In the framework of this Holy Year of 2000 it was unthinkable
that there should not be a Day of Jubilee for Prisoners.
Prison gates cannot exclude from the benefits of this great event
those who find themselves spending part of their lives behind them.
In remembering these brothers and sisters, I first wish to
express the hope that the Risen Lord, who entered the Upper Room
through closed doors, will enter all the prisons of the world and
find a welcome in the hearts of those within, bringing peace and
serenity to everyone.
In this Jubilee, the Church celebrates in a special way the
mystery of the Incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ. Two
thousand years have passed since the Son of God was made man and
came to dwell among us. Today as then, the salvation brought by
Christ is continually being offered to us, that it may bear abundant
fruits of goodness in keeping with the plan of God who wishes to
save all his children, especially those who have gone away from him
and are looking for the way back. The Good Shepherd is always going
in search of the lost sheep, and when he finds them he puts them on
his shoulders and brings them back to the flock. Christ is in
search of every human being, whatever the situation!
2. This is because Jesus wants to save each one. And with a
salvation which is offered, not imposed. What Christ is
looking for is trusting acceptance, an attitude which opens the mind
to generous decisions aimed at rectifying the evil done and
fostering what is good. Sometimes this involves a long journey, but
always a stimulating one, for it is a journey not made alone, but in
the company of Christ himself and with his support. Jesus is a
patient traveling companion, who respects the seasons and rhythms of
the human heart. He never tires of encouraging each person along the
path to salvation.
The experience of the Jubilee is closely linked to the human
experience of the passage of time, to which it seeks to give
meaning. On the one hand, the Jubilee is intended to help us to
remember the past, treasuring the experiences it has brought. On the
other hand, the Jubilee opens us to the future, in which human
commitment and divine grace must together fashion the time left to
us to live.
Those in prison look back with regret or remorse to the days when
they were free, and they experience their time now as a burden which
never seems to pass. In this difficult situation, a strong
experience of faith can greatly help in finding the inner
balance which every human being needs. This is one reason why the
Jubilee is so relevant to prison life: the experience of the Jubilee
lived behind bars can open up unexpected human and spiritual vistas.
3. The Jubilee reminds us that time belongs to God. Even
time in prison does not escape God's dominion. Public authorities
who deprive human beings of their personal freedom as the law
requires, bracketing off as it were a longer or shorter part of
their life, must realize that they are not masters of the
prisoners' time. In the same way, those who are in detention
must not live as if their time in prison had been taken from them
completely: even time in prison is God's time. As such it
needs to be lived to the full; it is a time which needs to be
offered to God as a occasion of truth, humility, expiation and even
faith. The Jubilee serves to remind us that not only does time
belong to God, but that the moments in which we succeed in
"restoring" all things in Christ become for us "a
time of the Lord's favour".
During the Jubilee, all are called to synchronize the unique and
unrepeatable time of their own heart with the time of the merciful
heart of God. He is always ready to journey with each one, at their
own pace, towards salvation. At times prison life runs the risk of
depersonalizing individuals, because it deprives them of so many
opportunities for self-expression. But they must remember that
before God this is not so. The Jubilee is time for the person, when
each one is himself before God, in his image and likeness. And each
one is called to move more quickly towards salvation and to advance
in the gradual discovery of the truth about himself.
4. The Jubilee is about change. The Old Testament Jubilee year
"was meant to restore equality among all the children of
Israel, offering new possibilities to families which had lost their
property and even their personal freedom" (Tertio millennio
adveniente, n. 13). The prospect which the Jubilee sets before
each one is therefore an opportunity not to be missed. The
Holy Year must be used as a chance to right injustices committed, to
mitigate excesses, and to recover what might otherwise be lost. And
if this is true of every aspect of life, since everything human is
capable of improvement, it is especially true of the experience of
prison, where life is particularly difficult.
But the Jubilee is not just about measures to redress situations
of injustice. It also has a positive intention. Just as in ever new
ways the mercy of God creates fresh opportunities for growing in
goodness, so also to celebrate the Jubilee means to strive to find
new paths of redemption in every personal and social situation, even
if the situation seems desperate. This is even more obvious with
regard to prison life: not to promote the interests of prisoners
would be to make imprisonment a mere act of vengeance on the part of
society, provoking only hatred in the prisoners themselves.
5. If the Great Jubilee is a chance for those in prison to
reflect upon their situation, the same may be said of civil
society as a whole, which every day has to come to grips with
the reality of crime. It can be said of the authorities who
have to maintain public order and promote the common good, and of those
in the legal profession, who ought to reflect on the meaning of
inflicting punishment and suggest better proposals for society to
aim at.
These issues have been addressed often enough in history, and
substantial progress has been made in conforming the penal system
both to the dignity of the human person and to the effective
maintenance of public order. But the unease and strains felt in the
complex world of the administration of justice and, even more, the
suffering attached to prison life show that there is still much to
be done. We are still a long way from the time when our conscience
can be certain of having done everything possible to prevent crime
and to control it effectively so that it no longer does harm and, at
the same time, to offer to those who commit crimes a way of
redeeming themselves and making a positive return to society. If all
those in some way involved in the problem tried to take advantage of
the occasion offered by the Jubilee to develop this line of thought,
perhaps humanity as a whole could take a great step forward in
creating a more serene and peaceful society.
Imprisonment as punishment is as old as human history. In many
countries prisons are very overcrowded. Some of them are equipped
with good facilities, but living conditions in others are very
precarious, not to say altogether unworthy of human beings. What is
clear to all is that this kind of punishment generally succeeds only
in part in addressing the phenomenon of crime. In fact, in some
cases detention seems to create more problems than it solves. This
must prompt rethinking with a view to some kind of reform: from this
perspective too the Jubilee is an opportunity not to be missed.
According to God's plan, all must play their part in helping to
build a better society. Obviously, this includes making a great
effort in the area of crime prevention. In spite of everything
criminal actions are committed. For all to play their part in
building the common good they must work, in the measure of their
competence, to ensure that prisoners have the means to redeem
themselves, both as individuals and in their relations with society.
Such a process is based on growth in the sense of responsibility.
None of this should be considered utopian. Those who are in a
position to do so must strive to incorporate these aims in the legal
system.
6. In this regard, therefore, we must hope for a change of
attitude, leading to an appropriate adjustment of the juridical
system. Clearly this presupposes a strong social consensus and the
relative professional skiffs. A strong appeal of this kind comes
from the countless prisons throughout the world, in which millions
of our brothers and sisters are held. Above all they call for a
review of prison structures, and in some cases a revision of penal
law. Regulations contrary to the dignity and fundamental rights of
the human person should be definitively abolished from national
legislation, as should laws which deny prisoners religious freedom.
There will also have to be a review of prison regulations where they
give insufficient attention to those who have serious or terminal
illnesses. Likewise, institutions offering legal protection to the
poor must be further developed.
But even in cases where legislation is satisfactory, much
suffering comes to prisoners from other sources. I am referring in
particular to the wretched state of some of the places of detention
where prisoners are forced to live, and the harassment to which they
are sometimes subjected because of ethnic, social, economic, sexual,
political and religious discrimination. Sometimes prisons can become
places of violence resembling the places from which the inmates not
infrequently come. Clearly this nullifies any attempt to educate
through imprisonment.
People in prison also find it difficult to maintain regular
contact with their families and loved ones, and structures intended
to help those leaving prison in their re-entry into society are
often seriously flawed.
Appeal to Governments
7. The Great Jubilee of the Year 2000 continues the tradition of
the Jubilee Years that have gone before it. On each occasion the
celebration of a Holy Year has been an opportunity for the Church
and the world to do something in favour of justice, in the light of
the Gospel. Jubilees have been an incentive for the community to
reconsider human justice against the measure of God's justice. Only
a calm appraisal of the functioning of penal institutions, a candid
recognition of the goals society has in mind in confronting crime,
and a serious assessment of the means adopted to attain these goals
have led in the past and can still lead to identifying the
corrections which need to be made. It is not a question of an
automatic or purely cosmetic application of acts of clemency. This
would not affect the essence of things: once the Jubilee is over the
situation would return to the way it was. It is a question rather of
fostering initiatives which will lay a solid basis for a genuine
renewal of both attitudes and institutions.
In this sense, those States and Governments which are already
engaged in or are planning to undertake a review of their prison
system in order to bring it more into line with the requirements of
the human person should be encouraged to continue in such an
important task, This includes giving more consideration to penalties
other than imprisonment.
To make prison life more human it is more important than ever to
take practical steps to enable prisoners as far as possible to
engage in work which keeps them from the degrading effects of
idleness. They could be given access to a process of training which
would facilitate their re-entry into the workforce when they have
served their time. Nor should the psychological assistance which can
help resolve personality problems be overlooked. Prison should not
be a corrupting experience, a place of idleness and even vice, but
instead a place of redemption.
To this end, it will certainly help if prisoners are offered the
chance to deepen their relationship with God and to become involved
in charitable projects and works of solidarity. This will help to
speed up their social recovery and to make prisons more livable
places.
In the context of these proposals, looking to the future and
continuing a tradition begun by my Predecessors in Jubilee Years, I
turn with confidence to State authorities to ask for a gesture of
clemency towards all those in prison: a reduction, even a modest
one, of the term of punishment would be for prisoners a clear sign
of sensitivity to their condition, and would surely evoke a positive
echo in their hearts and, encourage them to regret the evil done and
lead them to personal repentance.
Acceptance of this proposal by the competent authorities would
not only encourage prisoners to look to the future with new hope but
would also be an eloquent sign, at the dawn of the third Christian
millennium, of a growing worldwide affirmation of a justice that is
more genuine because it is open to the liberating power of love.
Upon all those responsible for the administration of justice in
society and also upon those who have incurred the sanctions of the
law I invoke the Lord's blessings. May God abundantly shed his light
upon each of them and grant them the fullness of his heavenly
favours. Assuring the men and women who are in prison throughout the
world that I am close to them in spirit, I embrace them all as
brothers and sisters in the human family.
From the Vatican, 24 June 2000.
John Paul II
|