A ZENIT DAILY DISPATCH
Varying Editions of the Liturgy of the Hours

By Father Edward McNamara, LC
ROME, 09 September 2014 (ZENIT)

Answered by Legionary of Christ Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy and dean of theology at the Regina Apostolorum university.

Q: Why is it that different editions of the Liturgy of the Hours in English have different texts for the readings? Specifically, the four-volume set of the Liturgy of the Hours has shorter readings than the single-volume "Christian Prayer" edition. This has caused some confusion among my friends as to which is the normative version. — C.M., South Bend, Indiana

A: There are probably several reasons.

First of all, various countries use different translations for the texts of the Divine Office. Sometimes this is because of copyright issues and sometimes simply the preference of one version over another. I believe that there are plans to develop a common text of the Liturgy of the Hours just as English speakers have achieved a common missal. However, it would appear that they are still in process and might take a long time.

Other languages spoken by various countries have similar differences, such as between the Liturgy of the Hours in Spain and in most Latin American countries.

Even in single-language countries such differences can occur because of changes to one area of liturgy not fully incorporated into the other rites. For example, in Italy, the bishops' conference has introduced a new official Bible and with it a new lectionary for all Masses using this new Bible. However, although use of the new versions is permissible, most printed editions of the Divine Office continue to use the earlier versions of psalms and readings.

The reasons why it might take longer to adapt the Liturgy of the Hours are many. First, the complexity of the Divine Office means that a new version will take time. Also, since the Liturgy of the Hours is often prayed and sung in common, the chants already prepared for the older version of the psalms will occasionally have to be adjusted and new books for instrumental accompaniment prepared.

Economic questions probably come into play. It must be considered that a new official version of the Divine Office would render the older versions obsolete from its official date of adoption, and no new editions of these would be printed. While it is probable that priests, deacons and laypeople could continue to use their current versions for private recitation, communal recitation would necessarily require the use of the new version. As in other countries, many parishes in Italy pray part of the Divine Office in common before daily Mass, and there is a wide range of inexpensive editions of the daily office to facilitate this practice. Religious communities especially would probably need to acquire the full four-volume set. It is one thing for a parish or religious community to buy a set of new lectionaries, another to buy multiple new copies of the Divine Office all at once.

In spite of these practical difficulties, it is probable that the Liturgy of the Hours will eventually be adjusted to the new texts. The Italian bishops' conference is notably generous in allowing the use of its official texts for free distribution and use by electronic means. This generosity will probably aid the eventual standardization of any new official version.

Regarding the English-speaking world, we could first say that the official version of the Liturgy of the Hours is the multiple-volume set. The three-volume set is the official version used in Great Britain, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand and several other countries in Asia, Africa and the West Indies. The four-volume set is the official version in the United States and Canada and probably some other countries as well. Recently some African countries have published their own version of the Liturgy of the Hours, which some consider the best version currently available.

The single volume of Christian Prayer is a reduced version of the U.S. edition of the Divine Office. I believe that there are currently two publishers with one-volume versions of the office on the market. These editions cater to individual lay faithful and small groups who wish to pray a part of the office, above all, lauds and vespers. One of these editions contains a condensed version of the Office of Readings for those who may wish to sample this particular office.

Not having a copy of the book available, I can only guess that the reason why some readings might be longer than the four-volume set is that a text spread over two days in the official text is condensed into a single reading in the single volume. Since the publishers probably intended the sample of the Office of Readings for private prayer rather than communal recitation, they did not worry about strict conformity with the official version. These single-volume editions are very worthwhile in helping to introduce a wider range of Catholics to the Church's official prayer in a comparatively economical fashion.

Many have discovered the personal spiritual benefits that derive from this treasure of sprinkling the day with moments of prayer and praise in union with the entire Church. Since this is the Church's official prayer it is also an exercise of the royal priesthood of the faithful and genuine active participation in the Church's liturgy.

* * *

Follow-up: Varying Editions of the Liturgy of the Hours [9-23-2014]

Related to our Sept. 9 reply on the Liturgy of the Hours, there was a question regarding some aspects of the Divine Office.

A Detroit reader asked: "The closing prayer for the proper in the [breviary] is the same as the collect from that office's Mass. Would it be appropriate to use the new translation in place of the one found in the current LOTH, as this could cause confusion in places where the Hours are prayed in public?”

This question has been answered in the affirmative by representatives of the bishops' conference. Either in public or private celebrations, the newly translated collects may always be used. However, this is not yet obligatory and will become so only with the publication of a revised Liturgy of the Hours.

In the same vein, the liturgical response "And with you spirit" should be used for all occasions, even in those books which are still awaiting a revised translation.

This article has been selected from the ZENIT Daily Dispatch
© Innovative Media, Inc.

ZENIT International News Agency
Via della Stazione di Ottavia, 95
00165 Rome, Italy
www.zenit.org

To subscribe http://www.zenit.org/english/subscribe.html
or email: english-request@zenit.org with SUBSCRIBE in the "subject" field


Bookmark and Share
Provided Courtesy of:
Eternal Word Television Network
5817 Old Leeds Road
Irondale, AL 35210
www.ewtn.com