THE VALUE AND MEANING OF THE NEW RULES CONCERNING THE PALLIUM
Marcello Costalunga


See Motu Proprio on the Conferring of the Sacred Pallium

"To the glory of almighty God, the praise of Blessed Mary ever Virgin and the holy Apostles Peter and Paul, in the name of the Supreme Pontiff, for the enhancement of the See entrusted to you, we bestow on you the Pallium taken from the tomb of blessed Peter as a symbol of the power of a metropolitan to be used within the confines of your ecclesiastical province." The form which is today pronounced by the Cardinal Deacon, who is senior by appointment, when in the name of the Holy Father he invests metropolitans with the Pallium, begins with these words. One notices that the form of words is somewhat modified when compared with that found in the Pontificale Romanum under the title "de Pallio." It is a modification which has been introduced into the more extensive work of the revision of the general norms for the conferring of the Pallium and it marks a significant enough stage in it.

The significant reaffirmation of the liturgical insignia which is conferred on metropolitans as a symbol of their authority adds nothing new. This is neither the place nor the time to outline the origin of the Pallium and the differences that there are about it between the Latin and the Eastern Churches (cf. G. Oriali, "La Collazione del Pallio", in Nuntia 1976, p. 88-96). But, readers should recall that Benedict XIV saw in it a certain symbol of the sharing of the pontifical authority in that it is "the principal sacred insignia of the Roman Pontiffs". (De Syn. XIII, 15,7). The same Supreme Pontiff, alluding to the ancient Roman tradition of blessing and conferring the Pallium, stated that "with the Pallium there is conferred on Archbishops the plenitude of the pastoral office" (ibid. II, 6,4); a symbol, that is, of the sharing in the fullness of the pontifical office, of the "archiepiscopal power" as was later stated in can. 275 of the Code of Canon Law.

But the fact is that the primary significance of the Pallium as a sign of the jurisdiction of the metropolitan in his ecclesiastical province, which is asserted in the Latin Church, has not a few times been completely obscured, if not absolutely robbed of its meaning, by its secondary significance as an insignia simply of honour. This came about when for reasons of history or considerations of merit the Pallium was given merely as a privilege to a diocese (and then to its bishop "for the time being") or even to a bishop as a strictly personal right.

There are twenty-nine archiepiscopal non-metropolitan sees to which the Pallium has been granted as a privilege of honour in the bull of the elevation of the see from an episcopal to an archiepiscopal one. Twelve of these are in Italy.

To these must be added the eighteen churches which actually enjoy the privilege of the Pallium. Seven of these are in Italy (Anagni, 19th May 1894; Arezzo, 26th October 1730; Pavia, 15th February 1743; Pozzuoli, 8th July 1961; Savona, 19th April 1915; Troia. 2nd June 1856; lege of the Pallium. Seven of these are in France (Autun, in the year 599; Chartres, 5th November 1917; Clermont-Ferrand, 28th January 1894; Countances, 17th July 1907; Le Puy—the official document granting the concession has not been found; Soisson, 1st March 1923; Tarbes and Lourdes, 8 December 1917; Verdun, 19th December 1906). Two are in Hungary (Pecs, 1st September 1754; Vac, 9th March 1906) and one in Poland (Warmia, 21st April 1742).

As to the personal privilege of the Pallium one can recall that on the 18th December 1884 Leo XIII conferred it on Monsignor Eugene Lachat, on the occasion of his promotion from the diocese of Basle to the titular archiepiscopal church of Dumïät, appointing him Apostolic Administrator of the Canton of Ticino. Again on the 7th July 1897, Pope Leo conferred the Pallium on Monsignor Gerlando Genuardi, Bishop of Acireale, for the twenty-fifth anniversary of his episcopate.

If one takes account of these facts one understands the value and importance of the "Motu Proprio" of Paul VI dated the 11th May 1978 and published on the 20th July: "On the conferring of the sacred Pallium in the Church."

The new Pontifical document was prepared by the Sacred Congregation for Bishops in consultation with the Dicasteries and the Commissions of the Roman Curia who have competence in this matter. It begins with the statement that among the episcopal insignia is the Pallium as "taken from the venerated tomb of blessed Peter the Apostle"—an expression which is not only full of significance but one which corresponds to reality. From the moment of the first Vespers of the Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul when the Pallia are blessed by the Holy Father, they are kept near the tomb of the Prince of the Apostles, waiting to be given to the metropolitans who have asked for them in the Consistory. The "Motu Proprio" then, having referred to the historical evolution of the Pallium in so far as its actual significance is concerned and having explained the reason for the decision, abrogates, for the Latin Church, all existing privileges whether local or personal and lays down that the use of the Pallium is reserved to metropolitans only and to the Latin rite Patriarch of Jerusalem.

Obviously, the Archbishops and Bishops who have the Pallium on a title of honour, will continue to use it as long as they remain pastors of the Church to which it was granted as a privilege.

Since the rules concern the whole church, in so far as the Eastern Church is concerned, canon 322 of the Motu Proprio "Cleri Sahctitati" which indirectly recognized the existence of some privileges in this matter is abrogated. The canon in fact specifies that the Pallium conferred by the Roman Pontiff on an episcopal See in perpetuity, or to a bishop "honoris causa" implies neither jurisdiction nor the title of archbishop or metropolitan "unless it is stated otherwise in the Apostolic Letter."

However, canon 239 §2 of the Code of Canon Law remains in force. According to this part of the canon the use of the Pallium belongs to the Dean of the Sacred College (or to another Cardinal, if by reason of age the Dean is excluded from taking part in the Conclave) as the consecrating Prelate of the one who has been elected Pope in the case where he is not already a bishop.

Perhaps it will be said that the revision of the norms relating to the conferring of the Pallium is not a problem of great juridical importance. However, the abolition of the privileges and the reservation of the Pallium to Metropolitans marks the first step in defining their rights and privileges according to new and suitable norms as envisaged by the Second Vatican Council (CD,40).

Finally, starting with recent Consistories it has been made possible for Metropolitans, if they so wish, to receive the Pallium (asked for in the Consistory either personally or through their representative) in their own cathedral church (cf. P. Siffrin, Enciclopedia Cattolica, IX, col. 646, "Pallio"). In such a case the Pallium is conferred by the Pope's representative in that area, also the better to emphasize the link with Rome. In fact, this is the other important aspect of the Pallium, that is, of being the symbol of a special communion which unites the metropolitan as such with the Roman Pontiff and which for this reason makes that union different from that of the other bishops.

Indeed we can bring this commentary on the document of Paul VI to a close by quoting the second part of the formula for conferring the Pallium: "May this Pallium be for you a symbol of unity and a token of communion with the Apostolic See; may it be a bond of charity and an incentive to practise fortitude so that on the day of the coming and the revelation of the great God and Jesus Christ the Prince of Pastors, you may receive the royal robe of immortality and a token of communion with the flock entrusted to you. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen."

 
Taken from:
L'Osservatore Romano
Weekly Edition in English
10 August 1978, page 3

L'Osservatore Romano is the newspaper of the Holy See.
The Weekly Edition in English is published for the US by:

The Cathedral Foundation
L'Osservatore Romano English Edition
320 Cathedral St.
Baltimore, MD 21201
Subscriptions: (410) 547-5315
Fax: (410) 332-1069
lormail@catholicreview.org


Provided Courtesy of:
Eternal Word Television Network
5817 Old Leeds Road
Irondale, AL 35210
www.ewtn.com